42 Comments
User's avatar
letztalk's avatar

I have lived in Alberta for my entire 74 years living in both Edmonton, Calgary and for the last 25 years in small town Central Alberta and I feel I can say that while there may be a small vocal group talking about becoming a US state, there is absolutely ZERO interest in this idea from the remaining 95% plus of the Alberta population. The upcoming AB referendum vote will clearly not get a majority but a 25-35% vote for separation will indicate there is still an large group of dissatisfied AB citizens with our current relationship within Canada.

While the ROC claims it can understand our concerns and wants us to stay it has yet to offer anything to work towards resolving our issues. Our issues are just not economic we also have equal concerns with governance issues like seat allocations, judicial matters, tramping down our desires to experiment with health care and our general package of values - ROC is progressive while AB (& Sask) are conservative. Just look at our federal voting preferences. We are as different & distinct within Canada as Quebec.

Sean Cummings's avatar

Watch now as the Liberals deal with another separatist matter in Quebec. The contrast will be SPECTACULAR!

Donald Ashman's avatar

You make a good point.

Donald Ashman's avatar

This was a good post, and I enjoyed reading what you shared.

As a small quibble, Ontario is far more like Alberta than you know. The smaller, rural communities are very conservative, and Conservative. It is only in the larger cities that progressivism takes hold. We simply have more people in those larger cities, compared to rural districts, compared to Alberta and Saskatchewan.

Secondly, you are correct that this Country requires a Constitutional makeover. That apathy has hurt the West, and Canada as a whole. There is absolutely no appetite nor stomach to begin such a process.

Good post, sir.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

If only 35% vote to have a future referendum, why would Canada bother to address their concerns?

letztalk's avatar

good point - but this attitude clearly illustrates why Albertans are pissed off.

Sean Cummings's avatar

I think because that's a hell of a lot of people to ignore.

Carole Saville's avatar

A Maritimes person commented, (not on this story) insinuating that he was the victim because his father had to work in the oil fields and that his father was away from his family for long periods. And to top that off, he commented that Albertans didn’t appreciate people from all over Canada coming here to ‘help’ us.

So, yes, the ROC doesn’t give a poop about Alberta and they continue to feel that they are victims of our prosperity.

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

Wah! Wah! Like I wasn’t away from home to work? But,I kept my salary in AB. Big difference! Liberals killed the fishing industry,foreign countries still dropping bets on our borders. Offshore Derrick work not good enough?!?

Carole Saville's avatar

Much of the ROC don't care about parts of the Maritimes as well. I am sure that the federal fishing and sealing regulations (1992 Northern cod moratorium) which devastated your economy, destroyed your way of life, and ensured a population decline was a grand experience for the folks in the east./sarc The Canadian federal government stepped in to help but if you talk to some of the folks from 1992, they might just tell you that the governments ‘help’ was at best deeply flawed. To date – Newfoundland has not reversed their population decline.

It is not just Alberta that has had the feds 'help'. A lot of us in Alberta know that, we just want the the pencil necked guy to go away.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

Just like Canada wants Alberta only to drain Albertan resources for its own ends. Or just suppress them in the cause of global climate.

The question is whether Alberta has more leverage and ability to play off Canada against the US as an independent state or a province.

Carole Saville's avatar

Exactly. And we certainly must have freedom before Carney allows the EU to rape and pillage.

Sean Cummings's avatar

>>it would be foolish to assume that the United States would want Alberta for any reason other than to drain its resources for its own ends<<

Because this has been absolutely happening to Alberta from the ROC for decades. At least back to 1905.

Donald Ashman's avatar

“Historically, The Heritage Foundation was the premier traditional, establishment conservative think tank. However, under its current leadership, the organization has pivoted to embrace "new conservative" populism and national conservatism.

Rather than fitting neatly into just one category, Heritage currently functions as an institutional bridge between the two eras of American conservatism.” (AI)

Okay; Professor Leach first conjures up his boogeyman and then proceeds to define a relationship and an influence that does not actually exist.

Because Donald Trump is influenced by Project 2025 and some of its recommendations, that does not immediately or logically segue into the notion that his administration is adopting every idea. The notions expressed by the two authors are just that: the ideas of two authors in a think tank.

If Donald Trump or another Administration were to desire to acquire Alberta as a resource colony, there are far easier and less expensive ways to achieve that goal.

Are we suggesting or assuming that an independent Alberta would retain no sovereignty?

Are American States resource colonies to the federal government or the executive branch? Do Texas, Oklahoma, and Pennsylvania not benefit from resource extraction and exploitation?

“• Economic Benefits: Oil and gas revenues account for roughly 7.6% of Texas's GDP and 5.7% of its total state and local revenue. The state produced over 42% of national crude oil and a quarter of U.S. natural gas.

• State Windfalls: Texas collects roughly 10.1% of all production value through severance and property taxes. It uses about 20% of this money to fund statewide public education permanent funds and its "Rainy Day" emergency reserves.”

I am by no means an expert, but it appears Texas is pretty pleased with the arrangement.

I get it that The Line is a platform devoted to a particular cause: that is Matt and Jen’s right.

But imagining goblins are under the bed or in the closet is not the same as actually being besieged with evil.

I truly hope Albertans decide to remain in Canada, but, with every day that passes, I understand better why they may not.

Carole Saville's avatar

Lately, Carney said that we had to prepare for the US to attack Canada. "Carney said he had prepared for the "extreme tail risk" that the Trump administration might order military action against Canada."

As you mentioned, Professor Leach first conjures up his boogeyman and then proceeds to define a relationship and an influence that does not actually exist.

Carney conjured up his boogeyman and no one comments.

Sean Cummings's avatar

Since pandemic the world has changed. Rule nothing out.

Carole Saville's avatar

I think you are trying to scare us about the wrong country.

Lest we forget, Carney is running as fast as he can to saddle Alberta and the rest of Canada with the EU which is just waiting to take away our sovereignty with their 170,000 pages of rules and regulations.

Farmers in Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba would face mandatory 50% cuts in pesticide use and risk, at least 20% reductions in fertilizer application, and a shift of agricultural land to organic production from under 5-10% today, all the way to 25% by 2030. Genetically modified canola, which dominates Prairie fields, would require costly segregation or outright phase-outs to satisfy the EU’s precautionary restrictions.

The Draghi report and industry analyses are clear: excessive bureaucracy and regulatory layering have eroded Europe’s industrial edge in these exact sectors — precisely the flexible, export-oriented industries where Canada holds competitive advantages today.

Separatists want freedom from bureaucracies, we don't want more.

Davey J's avatar

this narrative that canada is joining the EU is sad to see... is that all you got left in the tank?

John's avatar
Oct 2Edited

While you don’t have to agree with everything or indeed anything published by the Heritage Foundation their very existence would not be possible in the as totalitarian as possible Canadian broadcast environment. The so called hate speech controllers and bureaucrats in Canada would have hounded them out of existence a long time ago if they were Canadian.

So any Canadian interested in the free exchange of ideas should be grateful that their southern neighbors are spending their resources to make this forum possible. I remember a Canadian border guard seizing my copy of “black panther news” in the 1960s as “seditious literature” ( they also did it for gay literature in those days). Since nothing ever changes in burrocracy I’m sure that somewhere in the bowels of Ottawa pencil necked government paid elbozos are busily figuring out ways of blocking online publications to maintain “Peace, Order and Good Government” . After all if Iran and China can block the Internet, Canada should be able to do it also.

Brian Lowry's avatar

There's no need for the US to trudge through the long constitutional process of granting statehood, if Alberta were annexed. They would more likely simply annex Alberta as a territory and give Alberta the same sort of status as Puerto Rico. Which would give America unfettered access to all of Alberta's resources without the bother of creating a state. It wouldn't be great for Albertans, but it's very hard to imagine that Americans would care.

Davey J's avatar

Yeah they have no need to make Alberta a state, A state would have more independence and power than a submissive territory. The Alberta new leadership would be desperate for US recognition and protection; a territory will be accepted if offered. US has no reason to offer one inch more than is needed to get its hands on the resources.

A Canuck's avatar

It's almost always been the case that those who are supposedly shilling for an "independent" Alberta knew that the province would end up dropping into the laps of the Americans.

Articles like the Heritage Foundation material you found underscores this point.

My view on this is simple. If such people are so keen to be Americans, let them go to America and leave us (Canadians) out of it.

letztalk's avatar

I have targeted this submission in an above comment but I would like to broaden the topic of separation out in this missive with two points -one a general comment the other a question for all readers of this to ponder & reply.

General Comment- Alberta has been made out to be an outlier by even considering separation but lets look around the globe. Czechoslovakia amicably split in 2 about 20 years ago, the UK split from the European Union by a majority vote (we can debate why it hasn't been as successful as hoped in another post) but now both Scotland & Wales are seriously talking about leaving the UK and becoming separate, Ireland is seriously talking about becoming one, Catalonia has been trying to separate from Spain for years and now the Basque Region is also having discussions, also there are more than 15 other region in Europe in various level of talks regarding greater autonomy, oh yea isn't Quebec still taking about this - do you see a trend. People are mad at the status quo and want change everywhere.

My question to ponder & comment. Alberta biggest lever that is not talked about by both sides is what happens to British Columbia if Alberta leaves. Think about it and I'd love to hear your comments?

Carole Saville's avatar

Since World War over 100 countries have formed or gained independence in the last 80 years, about 25 of those new countries have populations under 6 million. Most of these new/separated countries are financially successful.

It is due to a 'small state advantage'. Governments can pivot faster; Alberta has good specific industries that we can make bigger and better and become a dominant force outside of Alberta. And we are resource rich, which should make all Albertans richer.

The 'scary' stories that are being spread about Alberta separation are predominant because the fall out for the rest of Canada is a bit scary. Yet Alberta gets the scare tactics, but the federal government doesn't suggest a solution. The reason for that is, that there simply is not a solution that will fit every province and territory in Canada, so if not now, eventually Canada will break up - and the reason will be bad/outdated federal governance.

As for BC, a transit-dependent coastal province, it would be to their advantage to play nice with Alberta. Should they choose to toll Alberta oil and gas (about 30 billion a year) Alberta could/would toll their 50 billion dollars to move through their neighbour Alberta to get their goods past Alberta.

letztalk's avatar

Your comment on Canada not being able to agree on anything pertaining to this huge country is bang on. I have already voted & I selected B on my mail in ballot. I don't want to seperate but a firm message needs to be sent.

Canada can be made to work by forming into four areas; the West, Ontario, Quebec & the Maritimes. An equitable division of power could be decided if all parties were committed.

Carole Saville's avatar

Like you I have been around for 74 years. I don't dislike Canada, but I hate the way politics in Canada has become more a game that leads to corruption, rather than taking pride in what Canada can be. With the governments playing one area of Canada against the other, I don't believe that these vote getting elbows up comments by and leader in Canada will be able to bring unity to Canada.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Again, I do not consider myself an expert, but I could find little connection between the views of Dr. St. Onge- a strong libertarian- and Donald Trump.

While E.J. Antoni III was a nominee for the Department of Labour, Donald Trump withdrew the nomination. Dr. Antoni’s ideas are, well, kind of out there.

Therefore, one could reasonably assume that neither of these economists is particularly influential with respect to government policy.

Boogeymen chased away; no more goblins under the bed.

Sean Cummings's avatar

This would absolutely not create a new National Energy Program. Depending on who is running the Alberta government, it would declare independence the next day.

Gregory Murray's avatar

Mr Leech is correct the if the Closet Annexationist leading the separation movement have thier way Alberta will be nothing more than Puerto Rico north.

Jim Hornett's avatar

I grew up hearing about freight rates. Then we got rail reform in the "80's and free trade ended the National Policy of 1879. We got the National Energy Program in 1982. I still think this was the most egregious piece of legislation passed in Canada. But Mulroney repealed it in 1985. Then we got Justin Trudeau and his hippy dippy ideas, one of the biggest being ending Alberta's oil industry. He represented a larger idea in the world that we needed to attack hydrocarbons in order to reach net zero. But that idea has now been revised and Mark Carney, the first Liberal PM who grew up in Alberta, is pushing forward new pipelines and has dropped Justin Trudeau's rhetoric and many of his ideas. So where are we now? we are moving ahead on increasing oil and gas production which will help the whole country. The Laurentian elite has treated us badly at times but we have always been able to force real reform. We will move ahead with low taxes and a welcoming attitude to new investment and Alberta will keep increasing its relative importance in the Confederation. I think that's all we can hope for under any scenario and its a future that I would be happy with.

Sean Cummings's avatar

Respectfully, which reform? How did we get to this place?

Jim Hornett's avatar

The Crow rate was dropped which eventually changed the grain industry and stimulated investment in the railroads.

Lana Charlton's avatar

Carney is still after Net Zero. The pipeline only got his blessing if the O & G industry would have added production costs of Sequestration. No benefit to the planet. Virtue signaling. Not even a level playing field within our own country as imported fuels do not meet these virtuous standards.

Jim Hornett's avatar

I wonder how much carbon capture and sequestration we will actually build. I am guessing not much.

IceSkater40's avatar

A lot of people I’m talking with have ordered advance ballots and have already sent them back. There’s been more political talk about this referendum than anything I’ve seen in a while and people are largely talking about voting to stay in Canada aside from the few family members I have who have been separatists for decades. I really hope this can be closed and the topic be put to rest with no future referendum lingering over our heads or court battles.

If the separatists win the vote it’s going to mean some hard decisions about whether my family starts looking at leaving Alberta. I won’t stay indefinitely while property values and employment opportunities decrease and I’m not sure how quickly those things might emerge.

Sean Cummings's avatar

It won't put it to bed unfortunately. They will lose this round. If they get their shit together and form a separatist party I imagine they will reach a lot of people who vote conservative but want nothing to do with its infatuation with MAGA crap as of late. Finding their own Rene Levesque couldn't hurt.

IceSkater40's avatar

I don’t worry about them forming their own party. It’s not popular enough for them to get elected - they’d already tried. But that’s at least a democratic way to go about things. The trips to the US and speaking on behalf of Albertans in the absence of being elected to represent us isn’t cool in my books and makes me believe that they wouldn’t be democratic if there was a separatist vote that won in the future.

They will all lose their collective minds when NDP wins though next year if the referendum comes out in their favor. Because that’s how this will go. UCP may already be unelectable. That’s the funny part about all this to me is they essentially have shot themselves in the foot for who actually gets elected in the next provincial election.

Sean Cummings's avatar

Separatism was a fart in the breeze 40 years ago. Not worth taking seriously. But times/generations have changed. Justin Trudeau I believe permanently destroyed Alberta's relationship with Ottawa. With likely 20-25% of the population suppporting Alberta independence here in 2026, that is called a movement. And movements tend to grow. (Sometimes they fizzle of course.)

I also believe that Danielle Smith has been taking on far too much crap because she is a woman.

Davey J's avatar

Forming a proper party is hard work, and takes multiple election cycles to gain enough seats to influence policy. Hard work is not something these separatists want to do. Just try asking them complex policy issues about what to do when separating; and they will feed you nonsense, glaze out, or insult you.

Sean Cummings's avatar

Yes it is hard work.

This matter is not going away after the 19th. It's a movement now. What that looks like, who knows, but I suspect party or not, on October 20th they will begin working toward a referendum again after losing this time (even though the 19th is not a referendum referendum, but a referendum on whether to have a referendum on independence.

If separatists are serious, then after then 19th they will begin anew. If they cannot build a new Parti Alberta with a credible leader, like their own Rene Levesque, there is zilch to worry about.