By: Greg Quinn
Canada’s decision to walk away from a trade deal with the United States appears to have incurred the wrath of President Donald Trump and every member of his administration.
Still: Good job, Canada, and what a good example for the rest of us to follow.
The United States under the current president is not a friend of the free world. It is not a friend of those of us who have sacrificed blood and treasure for it. It is not a friend who shares our values.
And, spoiler alert, it isn’t going to be for a very long time, despite the wishful thinking of those who want to believe that things will get back to normal after Trump leaves.
Why do I think that is wishful thinking?
There has been a generational change in U.S. politics, into which President Trump has tapped. Many Americans have a feeling of disillusionment with the world and a belief that the rest of us have taken advantage of the United States over the decades since the end of the Second World War.
In some ways (i.e. defence spending) that is a fair comment. We did free-ride on the United States. And we did so in the belief that our bluff would not be called. And, boy, has our bluff been called.
On defence, I have no dispute with Trump. He has, rightly, put the rest of NATO on notice and it was right that he did so.
But, apart from that, I probably disagree with everything else Trump stands for. Because, fundamentally, he stands against our core values of democracy, good governance, and the rule of law. He treats allies worse than enemies. He treats those of us who support such values worse than those autocratic and undemocratic states whom he seems to admire more than anything else (probably because he hankers after the absolute power their leaders have).
Those around Trump share his views and his dislike for the rest of the free world. J.D. Vance, Pete Hegseth, Marco Rubio, and Mike Johnson have all sold their souls for power and position. They are unlikely to change the U.S. approach should the Republicans be re-elected in 2028.
And let’s not hold out hope for the Democrats, either. Because of that generational change in U.S. politics, they will find it hard to row too far away from the politics of much of middle America. Those on the east and west coasts may get all the coverage because they shout the loudest. But they don’t hold all the power and they can’t always convince what is a silent majority.
For decades the rest of us were willing to “trust” the United States. Accept their leadership and generally move in lock-step with them.
That trust has been blown out of the water. All for what?
Trump talks about Making America Great Again. I guess it depends on your definition of great, but it seems to me that large parts of the world have completely lost trust and faith in the United States. And that will take a long time to get back.
However, it seems that much of the leadership of Europe and the United Kingdom (and elsewhere) hasn’t quite gotten the memo on the United States and how it is not (and will not be for a long time) the reliable ally it once was.
On this, maybe it is time for the rest of us to learn from Canada. To accept that sometimes you have to walk away from a bad deal. Sometimes you have to stand up to the bully, and sometimes you just need to do what is right — namely, call-out bad behaviour, call out inappropriate behaviour and say enough is enough.
That is what Canada has done. Prime Minister Mark Carney has done so in his more diplomatic language. Ontario Premier Doug Ford has done so in his own inimitable style.
Both are right. Sometimes you have to say enough is enough.
Canada is being punished for doing the right thing. It will hurt (although it will also hurt the United States). So, the rest of us need to stand beside Canada, work ever more closely with it, trade ever more with it, and accept that that might mean doing less with the United States or being “punished” by it for not being a lap dog.
Does my own United Kingdom and others have the courage to do this?
Canada has led the way in how to deal with the United States. We have more strength together than apart. If we work together, we can minimize the pain on ourselves and show the United States that they can’t always have it their own way.
Ultimately that will hurt Americans politically and economically and may make them become more — but not totally — reasonable. But to do that we need to stand firm and together.
Canada has shown us the way. It is now up to the rest of us to show that we have equal courage and determination.
Are we able to?
Greg Quinn, OBE, is a former British diplomat who has served in Estonia, Ghana, Belarus, Iraq, Washington D.C., Kazakhstan, Guyana, Suriname, The Bahamas, Canada, and Antigua and Barbuda in addition to stints in London. He runs his own government relations, business development and crisis management consultancy: Aodhan Consultancy Ltd (www.aodhaninc.co.uk).
The Line is entirely reader and advertiser funded. No federal subsidies, no bailouts. If you value our work, please consider supporting us by subscribing or making a donation. Donations are not subscriptions and do not unlock paywalled content, but they help keep The Line independent
To contact The Line with a general inquiry or comment, please email info@readtheline.ca. For other ways to connect with us or to follow us on social media, please see our LinkTree.
Standing up to Trump like Carney is doing will definitely attract the eye of Sauron. Trump is obviously not used to this and very much needs Canada's behavior to be punished so it won't spread. Hopefully the author is right and other nations will stand up also. Not doing so will just lead to the dissipation of Western society. No biggie.
"J.D. Vance, Pete Hegseth, Marco Rubio, and Mike Johnson have all sold their souls for power and position." It's chilling to watch old quotes from Vance and Rubio where they warn about the dangers of giving Trump power. They truly have abandoned their principles. Mike Johnson and Hegseth never had any to start with.
“Both are right. Sometimes you have to say enough is enough.”
Yes, and other times you must take a sober, introspective look at the situation and stop reacting nonsensically.
The author is a lifetime diplomat, so I think I am safe in assuming he knows that domestic politics and international relations are not mutually exclusive.
I would warn my UK cousin about taking Mark Carney at his word, but I shouldn’t have to, after Mr. Carney’s tenure as the Governor of the Bank of England.
Mr. Carney’s has suggested that Canadians should brace themselves for sacrifice; what if I have nothing left to sacrifice after eleven years of decay, defenestration, diminishment, destruction, and desecration of the Country I once loved?
I don’t have a defined benefit pension. I don’t have extensive government benefits. I can’t elegantly segue my career from diplomacy to consultancy and still keep all of my gathered eggs.
Please tell me what Mark Carney and the Liberal Party of Canada will sacrifice to pursue Mr. Carney’s Trade War.
Will his children have to leave their U.S. universities? Are Canadian universities not good enough?
Will his wife have to give up her no-show job in New York with Eurasia Group? Are there no left-wing think tanks in Canada?
Will Mr. Carney have to give up his American home or his other American assets? Why has he not personally invested in the Country he pretends to lead?
How long & how hard are you and your family members willing to work so that Mr. Carney’s sacrifice nothing?
How long will Canadians allow Mr. Carney’s Trade War to mask the very serious problems we have in this country? We have constitutional, economic, regulatory, bureaucratic, social, healthcare, and lawlessness problems that affect the everyday lives of Canadians. Those problems have only continued to worsen over the last eleven years.
So, before other Countries slip those Elbows Up and tighten the chinstrap, maybe they should take that same, sober second look at the best strategy forward; Don’t be Canada.