Discussion about this post

Commenting has been turned off for this post
Allan Stratton's avatar

This is really, really good. I'm on the left, but am concerned at the way our Supreme Court has increasingly invented law on the fly; our free speech rights came within a single vote of implosion recently in a ruling over a Quebec comic's joke. And while I initially cheered the creation of our federal and provincial human rights tribunals, I have become increasingly wary of their power-creep, as a critical mass of ideological members make rulings that have acquired the practical force of court rulings. (Several years ago, a self-identified transwoman in BC came close to winning a case that would have made poor, immigrant women wax that person's balls. Supporters of the hairy-balled claimant only fled when the person self-outed and their grift became clear. Although the specific individual lost their case for being a serial litigant, whether genitally male women can force women perform the service was, remarkably, left an open question.)

Expand full comment
Joel Freeman's avatar

Great article. I don't have much to add except that I've been reading a lot about Roe lately and this is the first article that boldly concedes Alito has a point while still writing from a Pro-Choice bias. The Left simply can't seem to engage on this topic without being clouded by the distastrous outcomes that will be inevitable. These outcomes are the blind spot of those on the Right. In the end I think successful human lives and a functioning society should overrule jurisprudence, and I guess that is an uncomfortable truth.

Expand full comment
149 more comments...

No posts