128 Comments
User's avatar
john's avatar

I thought Alberta wanted all the rights and privileges of Puerto Rico? Seriously, what's in it for the US to give Alberta statehood?

Donald Ashman's avatar

How many answers would you like?

raymond's avatar

Quick answer is that Puerto Rico doesnt really make sense if Albertans can just get voting rights just by getting into a car, and drive down.

IceSkater40's avatar

The anger/irritation/borderline rage that comes across in this is something I appreciate. I have family that are separatists and really, I have come to see them as just following the latest thing and not really understanding much about the bigger picture. The proverbial night your own nose off to spite your face.

What’s richer is that Britain is now having conversations about trying to rejoin the EU. You’d think maybe the separatists might realize that the expense of separation isn’t necessarily good for most people.

Donn Watt's avatar

Well said Jen. Spot on!

C S's avatar

Wow!! Strongly worded and amazing! It’s been obvious to anyone watching the separatist leaders have been grifting bozos the entire time, the recent legal digraces of Rath, Mohdry and Deer are telling. Is it not treason to meet with a foreign government to work out a deal to break up a country? Is that not illegal?

The US would take the state of AB over in less than 48h if it separated. Thank goodness this movement will fail miserably.

KayDee's avatar

Thanks for expressing why I think the last two years of this have been such a fucking waste of time and energy AND

other than JTs clearly anti O&G stance following TMX, can someone please explain to me, empirically, how Alberta, Canada's highest wage, high performing economy has been done dirty?

KRM's avatar

The entire Trudeau era was a 10 year slap in the face to anyone who didn't share the PM's hyper-performative Montreal-based identity politics. Yet we all had to suffer through it.

Consider all the far left activist judges that were appointed - a cringey term but I don't know what else to call them - coupled with criminal reforms based on the assumption that offenders are victims of the system.

The amount of money that was and continues to be wasted on the reconciliation black hole, and the amount that disappeared into covered up scandals like the Sustainable Development Fund.

The economic vandalism that happened during Covid when money was distributed almost indiscriminately with a firehose, driving inflation and a cost of living crisis that we might never really recover from.

The firearms bans and their repeated total arbitrary abuse of licened gun owners who are statistically the most lawful and safest demographic in the country.

The mass immigration that happened over the last 5 years, booming the population by over 10% (almost all of this in cities making the effect much more pronounced) without regard for capacity to absorb them or effects on society other than short term boost in raw GDP.

All of this is incredibly offensive. Without even dipping a finger into province-specific issues, I can see why a province where the majority strongly opposes this nonsense would not want to be ruled by a government that can impose it on them.

(Again, I don't support Alberta separatism and don't think it has any chance of success, but this is a big part of why I understand the sentiment.)

KayDee's avatar

I would suggest these are pan Canadian concerns, most of which I and most Albertans would agree with; However, they do not serve as a basis for a separatist argument.

KRM's avatar

Albertans are also probably pretty sick of the rest of Canada running around screeching about Donald Trump while they hit themselves in the head with hammers.

Donald Ashman's avatar

“Most of them are just grifters out to make a few bucks on rage bait crowdfunding.”

Well then, Jen, you have nothing about which to worry, do you?

Your appalling language does not make up for the weakness of your argument. Please accept that as it is offered.

If 51 per cent of Albertans support a vote to consider the idea of a referendum, are you seriously suggesting that would not change the dynamic between the West and the federal government?

Sixty or eighty years of what you describe as poor treatment by the federal government did not just happen in eleven years; I remember talking about Western Discontentment a very long time ago.

It is real, it is not imagined, and the can should not be kicked for another generation to suffer.

Neither should one stoop to scare tactics that one cannot back up properly with facts. Emotion won’t do it this time, Jen; folks have seen that con before.

I am not suggesting for a moment that you are being disingenuous or untruthful; but there are many problems in this Country that are not being addressed, and that hasn’t changed with the election of a “new” government.

I genuinely hope that Albertans choose to stay within Canada; yet, every day that passes, I understand better why they may not.

Larry's avatar

Jenn, very well said.

I also like the Puerto Rico comment. Take a quick trip to PR and see how you like the view from the trunk of 1949 Chevy because that the view a separate Alberta will ultimately have.

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

A rusted out Black Ram pickup…

Bruce Deacon's avatar

Dear Jen:

You have covered the fundamentals so well that the vast majority will be able to understand.

Of course, the separatists are driven by their passion so reason will not work. But on the stay side of this, your passion is very clear. So thank you, thank you, thank you.

Sincerely,

A 79 year old Ontario/Albertan who is proud to be Canadian, first and foremost.

Gerald Pelchat's avatar

Your comment about Alberta being thrown a couple of pipelines to keep us quiet, over simplifies the issue. While sockboy did do the west dirt vis a vis our major industry, will a couple of pipelines solve the overriding issues of rep by pop, judicial appointments, an unrepresentative senate, and yes, control of immigration and equalization? Pretty easy to throw out a few crumbs to keep the peasants from noticing that if it's not decided in Ottawa or Montreal it doesn't happen.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

> and yes, control of immigration

This is one of those things that I find very odd about Alberta separatists. And no, this isn't mockery, I genuinely do not understand the thinking.

If you wanted the same "control" of immigration that Quebec has.. ..you could ask for it. Alberta has never done that. It's one thing to complain about things you were denied, but when you've never even requested that from the federal government, let alone been denied, how is this a beef?

The closest anyone has got to trying to get that from Ottawa is Ms. Smith's referendum. And that's silly because she doesn't need it. It's as if she had a referendum on suspending provincial fuel taxes.. but she didn't have a referendum because she didn't need one.

To me that suggests the immigration issue is more about playing silly games to gin up "controversy" to boost her poll numbers. Getting influence on immigration isn't the point at all. than actually getting anything... because I don't know about you ... when I have the power to do something I want to do, I uh ... just do it.

That's something I just don't get about Alberta separatists.

Doug's avatar

No province has control over immigration. Immigrants are free to move within Canada. Restricting movement would require border controls between provinces. It is a stupid conversation. Best to focus on substantive issues like free flow of goods, services and capital between provinces and diminishing the oligopolies controlling the dairy, poultry, airline, media, telecom and financial services industries.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

Yes, but also "sort of".

I believe that to apply under the federal immigration, you need to say you intend to live outside Quebec. If the immigration board decides you lied about your intentions in coming to Canada, they can revoke your immigration status.

So if you say you want to live in BC, get approved and ten minutes after arriving move to Quebec, they might be a teensy bit suspicious that you lied on your immigration forms and revoke your status. Now, I don't know if that happens and I suspect it doesn't, but it's not so much that we have internal border controls and more that you can't lie on your job application.

Of course people circumstances change, so the same thing, but moving to Quebec 5 years later would not even mean theoretical problems... but of course people put down roots.

So yes, Alberta could get the same deal and people opposed to high immigration might like that. Quebec has a "target" of accepting their population share of the federal immigration numbers. but it's a "target". And right now, AI tells me they're accepting 12% of Canada's immigrants, despite having 22% of our population. Alberta might like that.

But it's worth saying again... they have never asked for it. So complaining they don't have it is weird.

Gerald Pelchat's avatar

Do you actually think CBA, or whoever, will keep track of that? There are half a million foreign students they can't account for. Once you land here and walk out the door you can ( and many do ) just disappear.

Doug's avatar

I think that only applies in theory to provincial nominees, which are a small percentage of immigrants. More.often than not, Quebec nominees selected based on their French language skills move elsewhere for better jobs, lower taxes etc.

Also, Section 6 of the Charter of Rights guarantees mobility to Permanent Residents and to citizens.

Wesley Burton's avatar

They could revoke it but will they? I dount it. I also doubt the revokation would stand up to a court challenge. The constitution guarantees freedom of movement. Not freedom of movement for just citizens.

Davey J's avatar

The 500K in mail in ballot requests tells me more than anything that the separatists are about the get whipped. Then of course, any social media accounts they control will go on about election fraud and THE LIBERALS! (along with all those people in international nations that took a course on how to make money on social media and will rage farm you for ad impressions - yes this is a big thing online). Then it will pass and they can go back to whatever it is they want to do.

D.V. Webb's avatar

Prime Minister “Fancy Socks” and Alberta’s current Premier are very similar. Narcissists who in pursuit of retaining political power, are willing to throw the very system that brought them into power under the bus.

To rid themselves of “Fancy Socks” some federal Liberals decided to “grow a pair”, remembering they were a party and not a cult. I do not have confidence that it will happen provincially. Smith is a political opportunist whose luck is running out. There is no floor for her to cross. The UCP is a den of vipers and she is the ringmaster. Perhaps podcasting is in her future?

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

She’s no Master. She strikes me as ‘Grass in the Wind’,hither and yon. Where the breeze takes her. I had high hopes. Not an adept two stepper,stumbling away

Rick Roberts's avatar

Peter Lougheed warned of the Americans coming after Alberta resources. His main concern wasn't fossil fuel, but water.

The Colorado River basin, which provides water to millions of people is drying out.

Who has lots of water, just about due north of the drought stricken area? Alberta.

Doug's avatar

Anyone looking at a map would know that Alberta has no water to give.

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

Yeah,and we need our water just as much if not more. We are the last who should volunteer this resource.

Michelle Marcotte's avatar

Finally, some tough-talking real sense. Thank God. I hope the question is clear (it seems rather muddled to me), and I hope all the sensible and realistic people of Alberta get out and vote to make the answer clear - to stay in Canada and improve things for Alberta and the rest of Canada. The US is circling the drain now, joining it would drag all of us into the whirpool.

Jim Hornett's avatar

I want to see all the federalists get out and vote and CRUSH the separatists. Then I want to see the UCP throw the separatist supporters out on their ear.

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

And Danielle Smith. Brian Jean sure been quiet eh?

PETER AIELLO's avatar

Quebec is on the verge of “sending a message”. What are your thoughts on that one?

Line Editor's avatar

I think it's stupid for all the same reasons. Also, I'm not in Quebec. JG

PETER AIELLO's avatar

A separation movement in Quebec could have the same effect as all those points brought up in your message wouldn’t it?

Donald Ashman's avatar

Stop making sense, Peter.

George Skinner's avatar

He isn't making sense, Donald, for all the various reasons Jen Gerson has laid out about Alberta and for the fact that Quebec's efforts at extortion haven't yielded any real benefits for that province and their voters know it. The CAQ is in trouble because they're an old, tired government. The PQ has a shot because they're not the CAQ, and even the PQ knows that the separatist talk is a liability for them.

David Lindsay's avatar

It is just as stupid, and should die the same horrible death.....and it will be in English only, something else I'm not sure they've really considered.

John's avatar

Your first sentence is consistent with your thesis. The second not so much. Evil or good is the same everywhere. And it’s easier to fight evil (if that’s what you truly believe) before it gets to your shores. A PQ majority will scare Ottawa into massive concessions. And encourage Albertans to do the same.

Donald Ashman's avatar

You make a good point.

IceSkater40's avatar

I also don’t think Quebec is really sending a message when they’re clearly saying we wouldn’t have a vote in these times. But at least Quebec politicians are doing it the honest way - through a democratic election. Separatists haven’t been able to get anyone elected who runs on a platform of being a separatist. I don’t see that changing in AB. Besides, the separatist movement was always going to eventually eat their own. We’re at the beginning stages of that so we shall see how that ends up.

Donald Ashman's avatar

I think you are wrong for the following reasons: first of all, Quebec has successfully used the threat of separation over and over and over again to wrench concessions from the rest of Canada. I don’t think that is being honest.

Secondly, one of the reasons the “Stay” folks use scare tactics and cudgels like the hysterical “vassal state” argument is that they really have no argument other than “it will be hard”. Many Albertans are like me, I suppose; I live in a riding that only votes Liberal. The denizens of “London Centre”, London, Ontario would vote for a burnt out stump painted red. My vote doesn’t count- never will- and never has.

Canada- and Canadians- abandoned me a long time ago. It took a long period of time, but I finally accepted the fact.

My point is, I suppose, what exactly do folks expect Albertans to endure? How hard and how long are Albertans willing to work to support the lifestyles, consumption, and leisure of the Rest Of Canada?

George Skinner's avatar

Your vote has always counted, and it has always been counted. If you think voting is only valid and your vote only counts if your preferred party wins, you need a remedial class in democracy.

Carole Saville's avatar

I saw a meme the other day, it read: "How can Alberta not sustain itself if it separates...

when it is already sustaining all of Canada?"

The arguments for the stay crew fall into several categories:

▪︎ the emotional thought that the Canada they think they know, still exists.

▪︎ they have done the math and determined that Canada and Canadians will be much poorer without the Western ATM.

▪︎ they are has beens of the political landscape who think they are still relevant.

The Green Clamp's avatar

Looking at 2024 figures, Alberta produced 15% of Canada’s GDP, vs. Ontario at 39% and Quebec at 20%, so “all of Canada” is a bit of a stretch. Of course, Alberta won’t be sustaining itself as an independent country, anyway. At best, maybe a US state, although a massive resource transfer to become a US territory is more likely.

Donald Ashman's avatar

A little harsh, but I get exactly what you are saying.

John's avatar

Quebec separatists have been able to get elected on their platform in the past. And lost their objective by what would be called a statistically insignificant margin.

David Lindsay's avatar

Quebec's separatist dreams will die in the same legal battles with Native Canadians about what they get to keep. And yes, after this many years, should they have one, I'd support a concurrent one about whether they get to stay.

KRM's avatar

Quebec separatism in 2026 is arguably even more laughably unserious than Alberta separatism. At least Alberta's is based on years of genuine rage and alienation more recent than the 1960's.

"We get everything that we want and more as part of Canada. The entire senior public service, any prominent Cabinet Minister and anyone hoping to become Prime Minister must speak our language even though only a tiny minority of our province can't understand English. We get to do whatever we want, we get equalization payments, and all our major industries get subsidies from the federal government. Obviously time for a secession referendum! Ok after we stop needing the fed to keep us safe from the mean US president that might bully us if we were independent. Of course."

John's avatar

And also as per one of Justin’s last policies all the Supreme Court justices must speak read and understand French without a translator.

I’m convinced your last point is why Carney decided to walk away from the deal. If only to help the Quebec federalist parties in tomorrow’s election.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

> And also as per one of Justin’s last policies all the Supreme Court justices must speak read and understand French without a translator.

Personally, I think this policy is a constitutional crisis waiting to happen. Mr. Trudeau was effectively trying to restrict the powers of future Prime Ministers and constrain them to act in a way he would like.

That's pretty contrary to a basic principle of parliamentary democracy that absent a constitutional change, one parliament cannot prevent a future parliament from acting in a contrary way and simply undoing what the first parliament did.

John's avatar

Couldn’t agree more. But JT didn’t seem to care as long as it gained him Quebec French votes. I think he was trying to piggyback onto his dad’s Official Languages act. The same act that has resulted in no unilingual person being promotable into any supervisory position in the Federal government. And that led to a recent statement (trial balloon) by one of the Carney ministers ( I forget which) that the working language for any Canadian company located in a “designated” francophone area would have to be French. As is now the case in Quebec.

KRM's avatar

That might have been part of it. I think walking out of the deal was intended as a short term play to seem tough and maybe get some concessions out of the US on a deal we were 99% of the way ready to live with, but is now indefinite because it's proved to be the most popular thing a Liberal has done in about 30 years.

John's avatar

Makes sense. And tariffs also bring in tons of money into Canadian revenues. Which can be used to brib.. (oops subsidize - affected voters)

Doug's avatar

The message loses resonance after 60 years.

John's avatar

I agree. The planned destruction of traditional Anglo Canadian moral values started by PET 60 years ago with the replacement of real freedoms with a watered down pretense of a charter, with official bilingualism and dilution of values through unchecked third world immigration on the Anglo side with no need to integrate, has pretty much been achieved after 2 generations. His son carried out mopping up operations including increasing civil disarmament, more immigration, dominance of the Federal civil service by Francophones etc, the removal of God and Judaeo-Christian symbols in government. It will take as long to recover IMO

Ray's avatar

Well said.

If there is one scenario I’m concerned about, it’s a robust showing for separatists but less than a majority. Then the seppies can start a bunch of Trumpite “stop the steal” BS and we start seeing “little green men” appearing in Alberta.

C S's avatar

Oh don’t worry the seppies will deny the legitimacy of the vote unless they win. They’ve learned from their idol the pedo in chief