31 Comments
User's avatar
Darrin Tyndall's avatar

What more can one say? International hockey competitions make bank in Canada. No Canadian tournament, very little money going to said hockey body. We do have some power! Glad to see we're using it.

Mark Kennedy's avatar

The Russians can outflank this financial lever, of course, depending on how much they think investing in a hockey p.r. campaign is worth to them. Ethical scruple won't cause the IIHF to care even slightly where the money comes from.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

Simple point, but a great one.

Russia needs to feel their status as a pariah state. And a weak pariah state at that.

HS's avatar

This is one situation where the elbows up metaphor is actually meaningful

Eric Samuel's avatar

Russia can begin its international reputational rehabilitation as soon as they exit Ukraine leaving it whole and sovereign, pay reparations and institute laws for them never to invade again.

The CAS can begin its international rehabilitation by firing the arbitrators who made such asinine ruling.

john's avatar

It's good to see that the federal government is making it clear to the IIHF that they need Canada more than Canada needs them.

I appreciate the article explaining it so clearly.

Lou Fougere's avatar

Why are US teams not banned ? Has the US not started an illegal war in Iran and a trade war with Canada?

Andrew Gorman's avatar

Why? Because they're not comparable.

Taking the most generous pro-Iran position, it's still undeniable that Iran has been pursuing and funding international terrorism for decades.

The comparison is dumb and you should feel bad for thinking of it.

Lou Fougere's avatar

I should “ feel bad” because your definition of war is different than mine. American imperialism since WWII has killed thousands but that’s ok. Got it.

George Skinner's avatar

Russia deliberately targets hospitals, schools, shopping malls, and other civilian infrastructure with the objective of killing as many civilians as possible and making the rest miserable. They commit atrocities in occupied territory, and kidnap Ukrainian children for re-education as Russians. You don't know what you're talking about when you try to equate that to American warfare since WW2.

Lois's avatar

Not sure what you think a legal war is, and surely Iran's funding of the poisonous Houthi, Hezbollah and Hamas terrorists should mean something. They treat people in their country badly too. Plus note that Trump has not allowed the US army to flatten all of Iran and instead is trying less lethal means that are not working, partly because countries are failing to uphold sanctions on Iran.

David Lindsay's avatar

If you step back, the US isn't that much different from Iran. They've bombed the crap out of three Middle Eastern countries, destroying 2 while killing tens of thousands of innocents. Yeah, they're supposed to be the "good guy with a gun", but that doesn't really exist. What they did in Iraq is no different than what Russia is doing now. All the US has accomplished is to embarrass its military, cause a global recession and make Iran a global power.

IceSkater40's avatar

The Iran war is more complicated than that. And trade wars don’t kill people.

Lou Fougere's avatar

Trade wars may not kill peoples but they sure can inflict life changing damage.

David Lindsay's avatar

There is a big difference between a physical invasion and even the idiotic bombing the US is doing in Iran. As for an economic war, it's irrelevant.

Lois's avatar

I seldom agree with Breakenridge's writing. But this article needs to get strong approval from everyone. Thank you Rob Breakenridge!

This is the right thing to do and thankfully Canada is doing the right thing this time. It's also surprising that Carney is doing this specific right thing. He's usually so eager to get into anything international with few words to the long suffering voters as to what he's up to and how much what he wants will rack up the debt.

Marie Illerbrun's avatar

Great column which I'm sure all Canadians agree with.

Garth Jolly's avatar

I won’t watch a single second of any competition that allows a team or individual representing Russia. And as much as I love the competition, that includes the Olympics.

Canadians must stand on principle and set an example for the world.

Terry Heisler's avatar

I agree completely Rob.

Terry Heisler

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

Hear! Hear! Thanks Rob! And the IIHL can go to hell as well. They went ahead and ordered jerseys for Canada in International Hckey thru a distributor of their choosing. What The Phaack! Who do they think they are? And to think Carney wants closer ties to these European snobs.

Debbie Molle's avatar

What an excellent bit of writing this is... Well done.

David Lindsay's avatar

Carney got this right. We shouldn't go to the men's Worlds in Germany if Russia is there....which I doubt.

jc's avatar

I’m sorry, but this is typical Canadian self-congratulation: imagining we’re setting an example for the world by making the almost entirely costless gesture of excluding some Russian teenagers from a hockey tournament. Great. Another opportunity to congratulate ourselves on our moral leadership while our military remains in shambles, with meaningful improvements perpetually promised for some future date.

It’s much easier to make a show of standing for something than to actually sacrifice something for it.

Erik CvS's avatar

Why are you deflecting? It is not helpful - and the cost is zero other than some theoretical future Russian retaliation. Either you are for or against this stand - and, yes, the position that the Canadian government has taken does matter and I am in whole-hearted agreement with it. It may be low-hanging fruit but that doesn't mean we should ignore the topic.

jc's avatar

I think you’re making my point for me. You say my criticism isn’t helpful. Helpful toward what end, exactly? You agree this gesture costs us nothing. Fine. But if helpfulness is our standard, shouldn’t we ask what this actually accomplishes before celebrating it as an example of moral leadership for the world?

I’m perfectly fine with excluding Russian teams from this tournament. But let’s not elevate an almost costless symbolic gesture into some grand example of moral leadership for the world to follow.

C S's avatar

Agree Rob. This is a strong and appropriate move by Carney, even if its small and largely symbolic.

The world has not yet grown completely numb to the awful war in the Ukraine.

It does make you wonder what the IOC will do with Israel? Nothing I suspect but at least Canada has done the right thing in this instance. If Russia wants its athletes competing, it should stop killing innocent people.

@slacker1969's avatar

This means nothing to me, IRGC has 700 + members living and watching hockey in Canada. The last thing we need to worry about is Russian teenagers playing hockey. More Virtue Signaling from our government.