I doubt that. You underestimate the influence Carney wields over many of my fellow baby boomers. I pay attention to them. They do not merely support his policies, they tend to treat his judgment as self-validating. If they have even noticed he has restricted immigration while they are busy flapping their elbows and if he reopens immigration, I expect those now applauding his restrictions to recast expansion as a brilliant economic strategy. Whatever position Carney adopts, they will find a way to insist that he is right.
"They do not merely support his policies, they tend to treat his judgment as self-validating."
I think you hit on something about why Mark Carney is so uniquely popular and immune to criticism. Through a combination of circumstances and media coverage, a large portion of the population accept any decision by Carney as correct simply because he made it. Indeed, much of the media seem to have led the way on this, foremost the Globe and Mail.
If he continues a Trudeau-era policy, it must have been a good one worth keeping. If he changes 180 degrees and adopts what until then was derided as an unacceptably right-wing policy contributing to the destruction of the planet, well that's just him being wise and pragmatic. If he gets a deal with the US, he's a great negotiator. If he doesn't get a deal with the US, he's protecting Canada from the Orange Bully. He literally cannot do wrong because any action he does is right, otherwise he would not have done it. What do you call that, tautological correctness?
I've never seen such brainless cult-like behaviour among Canadians, who even at the best of times are unusually pliable and generous to their leaders.
Maybe because, like me, they respect his intelligence and experience. I don't agree with everything he's done, but I have enough respect for him to give him the latitude because of his proven abilities, and the fact that I know I don't have all the info he does.
I guess that depends on what experience you’re talking about. It amazes me that we’ve handed the country over to people who cut their teeth at Goldman Sachs and somehow regard that as reassurance.
And don’t get me wrong. I recognize my own baby boomer privilege. Carney hasn’t even mentioned OAS reform yet. I might start taking him seriously if he did. Why I gave up on Morneau after he drank the koolaid. With the right planning and help from someone like me, a 75-year-old couple can retain some OAS on a combined income of $370,000. Perhaps our generation’s enthusiasm deserves a little scrutiny.
That may not be your motivation, but don’t mistake greed for respect. Some of us have very good financial reasons to applaud the status quo. That doesn’t make it good policy for the generations coming after us.
The thing about Carney and McKinsey/Goldman-Sachs types is not that they've been right about everything - they've made some big errors in their time - but that their focus is on achieving results and they'll modify their approach based on data and experience. The Trudeau approach of greatly expanded immigration was a failure, full stop. A pure politician like Trudeau may get trapped by the romance of their ideas and hubris, and refuse to change approach. Bankers and finance types are acculturated to look at the bottom line and change course when things aren't working.
That misses the point. Results for whom? A policy can work beautifully for employers seeking cheaper labour while leaving workers facing stagnant wages and higher housing costs. My concern is whose interests they serve. You say they watch the bottom line. Whose? Personally I have been hedging my bets by being overweight in Brookfield. One interesting thing that happened lately is they just quietly shut down the ROC loophole for income flowing from Bermuda for unit holders.
I dislike the status quo just as much as you, and for the same reasons apparently.
Yes, he cut his teeth at Goldman Sachs, not necessarily an auspicious place to work given their role in the 2008 meltdown, but he left five years before that. It's more his careers at the Banks of Canada and England. You don't get jobs like that by being a lightweight.
I have 51 years lived experience with bankers. Two ridiculous situations going on right now. I don't hold them in the same regard as many other people and have the receipts. I guess we will see what comes of all of this. Given that OAS reform has to be done, he could at least give it a passing mention unless of course he knows exactly what he is doing. Catering to his base at the expense of everyone else.
From what I’ve observed you get jobs like that primarily by knowing and supporting the right people. That’s why people pay huge fees to attend elite schools like Harvard, Yale, Eton and the like.
The economic incentives for Canadian federal and provincial governments to support MAiD expansion is too little discussed. The activists and pressure groups who keep talking about "rights" are just useful idiots.
The gangsters of the 1930s Murder Incorporated group must be turning over in their graves with envy. The MAIDerer group Dying with Dignity raised and spent in excess of $1 million in ads and publicity in the last year. (For more I recommend sub-stacker Kelsi Sheren). One of the spokespeople for DWD commented on the government decision to defer indefinitely the use of MAID in cases where suffering was solely due to mental illness, was a violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. I thought you had a right to life. But I guess that’s another American lie.
“With the right planning and help from someone like me, a 75-year-old couple can retain some OAS on a combined income of $370,000.”
That's a good trick. My wife and I are boomers whose combined dividend income ensures we never receive a dollar of OAS. That doesn't bother us: our financial security is beyond threatening without this superfluous bonus. Why would we begrudge 'our' OAS entitlement being allocated to seniors who actually need it, when we already have enough to have gotten both our daughters and their families into houses of their own, with no impact on mom and dad's lifestyle whatsoever? 'Someone like you'—what are you, a tax evasion specialist? How far ahead of the game do the financially fortunate have to be before they feel 'secure?' Your post leaves it unclear in which direction you envision OAS 'reform' ideally going.
Are you arguing with me or agreeing with me? I've been advocating OAS reform precisely because the current system allows affluent seniors to collect benefits they don't need.
As a CPA, I help people arrange their affairs within the law. That's tax planning, not tax evasion. The fact that the rules permit something doesn't mean I think the rules make sense.
Are you comfortable with the scenario I described? A 75-year-old couple with $370,000 in combined income retaining some OAS? And that's just the income visible on their personal tax returns. Factor in wealth and income accumulated or retained through corporations, trusts and estates, and their actual financial resources could be substantially greater.
That's precisely why OAS reform should consider a wealth test, or at least some mechanism for accounting for income and economic benefits enjoyed indirectly.
The question isn't whether someone can structure their affairs to collect OAS. It's whether taxpayers should be funding OAS payments to people who plainly don't need them.
1) reduce the threshold at which clawback begins, maybe 60K,and that at which OAS is completely clawed back, maybe $90K. I'd have to build a model to figure out the exact thresholds to ensure it doesn't create discontinuities
2) base above thresholds on an average if several years income to reduce gaming
3) eliminate the extra amount introduced by Trudeau for those 75 and over
4) reduce indexing for a few years to put OAS back on trend. Trudeau increased amounts in excess of inflation
That is one way. You could also own an investment corporation with a large tax paid shareholder loan and pay tax in the company and draw down the shareholder loan.
My goodness Martin, some of your post almost sounds genuine.
Then I look at your profile and see you subscribe to Conrad Black, Brian Lilley, Poilievre, and others. All spouting propaganda and lies.
So, I will have to read your comments with that in mind. That is to say you have an agenda, just simmering beneath your words. Rather than sound like a bombastic buffoon like Poilievre does, your post is a little more troubling, because it’s clear you are trying to cast aspersions on Carney.
Again, considering majority of your choice of subscriptions being the epitome of fake news, fake and rage posting outlets, and outright lies by the MAGA owned Hedgefund-backed Post Media outlets.
Hmm. Well, I'm a boomer and I certainly don't support an increase in immigration. In fact, I don't support much of anything he's done. Which isn't much.
“It’s not quite so simple, but it’s true enough to note that Carney has both distanced himself from, and even dismantled, much of Justin Trudeau’s legacy. And in doing so, he has reaped political benefit.”
This statement is demonstrably false.
Canadians let Mark Carney change the filter, without changing the oil .
I doubt that’s anymore true than saying most of the Republican Party is now MAGA. A lot of the support within caucus that Trudeau had was because it’s full of people who want power, not because they had any real investment in his ideology beyond it being popular. They were, and mostly still are, cowards who are just trying to keep their jobs.
The immigration level was not decreased at all, compared to previous levels over a longer term.
Canadians have been misled again, and will reward the same miscreant politicians by electing them again, and again, and again.
So, the entire premise of the essay is incorrect; the immigration levels have never returned to previous levels, so the Great Economic Savant- The Dithering Darling of Davos- cannot claim to be enhancing immigration numbers as they have never truly been reduced by a significant extent.
Call me a radical but I would rather the government focus on more housing to enable younger people to be able to afford a home instead of increasing the number of competitors to those homes.
Cut off benefits and social services, make it an offense for employers to hire them without a valid SIN, permanent ban on re-entry to Canada for anyone without a valid visa who doesn't check out on the way out create a hostile environment. Most will go voluntarily.
Even offering them a plane ticket home is worth it.
You are talking about two different classes of people here. For those here illegally (e.g., no visa, a tourist visa but working illegally, or the rare "refugee" whose "asylum" claim has been denied but he's still here) they should be deported under current procedures. No need to call it re-migration, voluntary or otherwise. It doesn't matter whether they want to leave or not. They shouldn't be here.
Getting people who are here legally to change their minds and out-migrate themselves is another thing altogether. One way would be to cancel TFW visas en masse and stop hearing asylum claims. Then the ex-holders and rejected claimants have to leave, and they become ineligible for free health care. For permanent residents ("landed immigrants"), they can still be deported at the pleasure of the Crown even if they haven't done anything wrong. Once their status is rescinded, they have to leave. So the government can re-migrate any number of non-citizens it likes.
Unfortunately many of these deportation orders issued now are being contested in Court and some federal Court judges are exceedingly sympathetic to immigrants and the diversity they represent, even ones the government really wants to deport for having committed serious crimes in Canada or who make bogus claims for asylum such as for being trans-gendered in the U.S. I can't see wholesale re-migration of people who haven't done anything wrong in Canada -- we just don't want them here anymore -- being upheld. People who are making a go of it in Canada probably wouldn't be persuaded to return to the old country just for a plane ticket. And the deadbeats probably find the social safety couch more comfortable here than back home.
Re-migration involves some nastiness. Canadians are "nice" but not really very kind. We could do it, but we'd have to really want to.
I think this is spot on. I like Jen's "we don't talk about Truuudough", but the man's actions still have consequences, one of which is killing any chance of a successor using immigration as a policy lever safely.
There are exceptions... it would probably be a safe move if every one of them was a family doctor starting a family practice clinic close to your home or workplace... but that's about it. Actions have consequences and the LPC trashed immigration... likely for a long time. And it was the LPC, not just Mr. unnamable, Mr. Carney's current crop of MPs all went along with it.
It's unfortunate, but it is what it is.
If the LPC wants to revive an immigration consensus, they probably need to put a tighter focus on language and cultural issues. And yes, that probably does mean a lot less "we'll coddle your lack of our languages" and more "you are not eligible unless you're already perfectly fluent". Think about it.. we provide voting assistance in more than two dozen languages other than English, French & indigenous languages... We gave voting rights to people who cannot even speak our common tongues.. how can you be part of our society if you can't even communicate with your fellow citizens properly?
It's bizarre.
And yes, it might also involve a lot more careful scrutiny of immigrants who come from parts of the world with completely incompatible social values. And yes, it might also mean inserting a delay between the right to live and work in Canada and put down roots and becoming a citizen. Currently the minimum time is three years. Is that enough time to assimilate someone into our culture? I mean.. I like a lot of countries, but truly integrating would take a lot longer than three years for any of them.
These are the consequences of the LPC getting so deeply, deeply unserious. They broke our trust on immigration and rebuilding that takes time and difficult actions.
Or how all our beliefs about human rights, liberalism, and equality are simply a culture manifestation and how mass immigration from different cultures will eliminate them all.
Our economy now has two sectors: people who work at useful jobs and people whose income comes from liquidating and selling assets, private or public. Mass immigration suppresses wages and so harms the first group while benefiting the latter by reducing their cost of living.
The latter group are Carney's voters: boomers and broad public sector employees.
The only way immigration harms Carney is if outrage among those harmed builds to the point that the beneficiaries are carried along against their financial interests.
The second sector fits my economics prof’s definition of the “service economy” - people who earn a living from taking in each other’s washing. And let’s not forget entitlement hounds In Carney’s voter classes.
They mostly aren't even doing that. Given large deficits, most govt beneficiaries are simply being paid by rapidly increasing govt debt, and their "work", if any, is of little value. Retirees are doing nothing useful by definition.
I think carney will likely get a couple years grace. One, increased immigration effects take time to show up. Two, as long as Trump is in office it’s difficult to imagine another party taking control of parliament in an election.
But I am in the camp of those Opposed to an increase in immigration. However, on a practical level, the woke policies in schools have created generations of kids not having their own kids and not getting married. As long as that’s happening, then immigration is necessary not only for limited growth, but for even maintaining the current population. That makes the immigration topic complicated because multigenerational Canadians find themselves in a position of becoming a minority, largely because of the decisions they’ve made and the things their own children have been taught. And that is an issue.
But I don’t think maintaining our population via immigration is the answer. I think it’s less fear around climate change and humans killing the planet. More values continuing to be shared around family and the value of children. We’ve stopped valuing children in the same way. I know some will agree with me, but take a look at birth rates and see where population actually grows. It’s immigration more than Canadian births. I view that as a problem.
Creating an environment where young people are discouraged and prevented from forming families and having children is perhaps the most destructive cruelty perpetrated by our current society. Most young Canadians still theoretically want their own children, many of them are just at a loss as to how to make it happen, or how to manage it financially and psychologically.
> However, on a practical level, the woke policies in schools have created generations of kids not having their own kids and not getting married.
While I'd agree those policies have negative effects, that's not what's causing drops in fertility. (We know this because you see it in other places).
But you know what's common to all those places? Higher costs on marriage age people and higher costs of raising kids. And that fits with my experience... most people I know say "expensive" when the subject of kids comes up. And surveys continuously show that people have fewer kids then they say they want to have.
If you make something expensive, people have less of it.
The establishment has spoken. The great saviour saved a lot of wealthy insiders' bacon. The opposition made promises too far outside the desires of the managed state, would have made too many changes that would hurt established interests, so were successfully cast through a relentless propaganda campaign as an unacceptable choice, beyond the pale.
Those who screech this or that nitpick are just admitting that they swallowed it. Truth is, there shouldn't even BE a Liberal Party after what Trudeau did.
But we don't get to choose in this country, the choice is made for us. He might very well get the Nobel Prize. The establishment rewards their own.
"How the heck did that guy get a Nobel... he doesn't even have to whine and pretend that he won after extorting one from a lady whose country he invaded! It's not fair!".
Nobel *peace* prizes are absurd. Henry Kissenger, Barrack Obama, Yasser Arafat? Good grief, those are stupid choices. But it's just pathetic to be thirsty for one.
And that's probably the least fucked up thing he did. He was in charge of immigration from 2021 to 2023. He should be working at McDonald's but not trusted near the deep fryer out of fear he'll burn the place down, with a resume like that.
Carney walked out on a trade deal that would likely have limited the damage to Canadian jobs.
The following is from Blacklock's Reporter this morning where they quote the labour department who wrote the following in a Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement.
"Foreign tariffs have already significantly affected Canadian industries reliant on trade with the United States including lumber, steel and aluminum, automobiles and agriculture,” said the notice. A jump in EI claims was “disproportionately higher in tariff impacted sectors” including 44 percent higher among steelworkers in Northern Ontario. “The Employment Insurance region of Oshawa, for example, saw a 400 percent increase in regular claims,” it said.
“United States tariffs could place approximately 87,000 Canadian jobs at risk including roughly 52,000 direct exporter jobs and approximately 35,000 jobs linked to suppliers and service industries,” said the Analysis Statement.
The 87,000 figure was sourced with approval from an August 26 story in the news site The Hub, “New U.S. Tariffs On $28 Billion In Canadian Goods Put 87,000 Jobs At Risk, Economist Estimates.” The article quoted University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe, a former Privy Council consultant."
As the number of previously trained, hard working Canadians who are forced out of work grows, they too will join an unemployment line that is being filled by too much immigration.
> Carney walked out on a trade deal that would likely have limited the damage to Canadian jobs.
In the short term in exchange for long term damage.
The US wanted to control our ability to make trade agreements with other countries. That's an obvious "we'll stop punching you as long as you lie down and let us put a knife to your throat". That's suicide.
But yes, you're right... it would have helped us in the short term.
The more we delay a selttlement the more I feel that PM Carney is actually in agreement with President Trump's objective of shifting government revenues more towards tariffs and less towards income taxes and consumption taxes. The more a settlement is delayed and people adapt to the new regime the more likely it will be on permanent. I see the elbozoery and French Language histrionic heroics (😆) as being a smokescreen (fog of the trade war?) to hide what will be the new reality. Even the PM I believe admitted any new agreement would not get rid of tariffs. Just my .05s worth (loonie's worth in 2026).
Besides the economic arguments over immigration, Canada needs to revisit official multiculturalism. It seems at odds with both the human nature to socialize and the desired outcome of a shared national purpose. Multiculturalism, i.e. incentivized non-assimilation, only benefits politicians who can more easily target groups, and community leaders' need for emoyment.
There’s an interesting article by Lorne Gunter in the Edmonton Journal (Oct 3rd) that suggests Carney really hasn’t reduced immigration as he has claimed. Worth a read
"The poll shows 52 per cent of Canadians in favour of the country accepting fewer people with 35 per cent content with the current level. That’s very few leftover to fall in the “controlled increase” camp."
The controlled increase Carney spoke of was population. You're conflating it with a controlled increase to immigration levels. Note that the 35% refers to "maintain current immigration levels", not current population.
Agreed. Immigration helps prop up real estate values and confers leverage to public sector employees who can build the narrative that demand for their services exceeds supply
It's hard to know how to react to Carney's statement without any details. The Harper-era immigration system also led to an increase in Canada's population, but at a rate and with a set of criteria that resulted in widespread acceptance before Trudeau blew it up. Carney's clearly indicating that he's not going to go to the near-zero immigration approach advocated by some people, but I suspect that block of voters wasn't in Carney's column anyway.
Carney's taking a risk floating statements like this without details. People might be willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for now, but he's also potentially giving opponents a blank canvas on which they can project extremely negative possibilities. That could turn public opinion against Carney, and a more experienced politician should understand that it's dangerous to let your opponents define the terms of the debate.
I don’t disagree with what you’re saying, but I think not being an experienced politician is actually Carney’s strength, even though he’s had to stick handle a fair bit in prior roles. Having someone else erroneously define the terms of debate is something I think a capable person could easily deal with.
I doubt that. You underestimate the influence Carney wields over many of my fellow baby boomers. I pay attention to them. They do not merely support his policies, they tend to treat his judgment as self-validating. If they have even noticed he has restricted immigration while they are busy flapping their elbows and if he reopens immigration, I expect those now applauding his restrictions to recast expansion as a brilliant economic strategy. Whatever position Carney adopts, they will find a way to insist that he is right.
"They do not merely support his policies, they tend to treat his judgment as self-validating."
I think you hit on something about why Mark Carney is so uniquely popular and immune to criticism. Through a combination of circumstances and media coverage, a large portion of the population accept any decision by Carney as correct simply because he made it. Indeed, much of the media seem to have led the way on this, foremost the Globe and Mail.
If he continues a Trudeau-era policy, it must have been a good one worth keeping. If he changes 180 degrees and adopts what until then was derided as an unacceptably right-wing policy contributing to the destruction of the planet, well that's just him being wise and pragmatic. If he gets a deal with the US, he's a great negotiator. If he doesn't get a deal with the US, he's protecting Canada from the Orange Bully. He literally cannot do wrong because any action he does is right, otherwise he would not have done it. What do you call that, tautological correctness?
I've never seen such brainless cult-like behaviour among Canadians, who even at the best of times are unusually pliable and generous to their leaders.
So agree with this!
Maybe because, like me, they respect his intelligence and experience. I don't agree with everything he's done, but I have enough respect for him to give him the latitude because of his proven abilities, and the fact that I know I don't have all the info he does.
I guess that depends on what experience you’re talking about. It amazes me that we’ve handed the country over to people who cut their teeth at Goldman Sachs and somehow regard that as reassurance.
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/the-great-american-bubble-machine-195229/
And don’t get me wrong. I recognize my own baby boomer privilege. Carney hasn’t even mentioned OAS reform yet. I might start taking him seriously if he did. Why I gave up on Morneau after he drank the koolaid. With the right planning and help from someone like me, a 75-year-old couple can retain some OAS on a combined income of $370,000. Perhaps our generation’s enthusiasm deserves a little scrutiny.
That may not be your motivation, but don’t mistake greed for respect. Some of us have very good financial reasons to applaud the status quo. That doesn’t make it good policy for the generations coming after us.
The thing about Carney and McKinsey/Goldman-Sachs types is not that they've been right about everything - they've made some big errors in their time - but that their focus is on achieving results and they'll modify their approach based on data and experience. The Trudeau approach of greatly expanded immigration was a failure, full stop. A pure politician like Trudeau may get trapped by the romance of their ideas and hubris, and refuse to change approach. Bankers and finance types are acculturated to look at the bottom line and change course when things aren't working.
That misses the point. Results for whom? A policy can work beautifully for employers seeking cheaper labour while leaving workers facing stagnant wages and higher housing costs. My concern is whose interests they serve. You say they watch the bottom line. Whose? Personally I have been hedging my bets by being overweight in Brookfield. One interesting thing that happened lately is they just quietly shut down the ROC loophole for income flowing from Bermuda for unit holders.
I dislike the status quo just as much as you, and for the same reasons apparently.
Yes, he cut his teeth at Goldman Sachs, not necessarily an auspicious place to work given their role in the 2008 meltdown, but he left five years before that. It's more his careers at the Banks of Canada and England. You don't get jobs like that by being a lightweight.
I have 51 years lived experience with bankers. Two ridiculous situations going on right now. I don't hold them in the same regard as many other people and have the receipts. I guess we will see what comes of all of this. Given that OAS reform has to be done, he could at least give it a passing mention unless of course he knows exactly what he is doing. Catering to his base at the expense of everyone else.
Getting a job and doing a GOOD job are two different things.
His tenure at the B of E is widely regarded as a disaster.
From what I’ve observed you get jobs like that primarily by knowing and supporting the right people. That’s why people pay huge fees to attend elite schools like Harvard, Yale, Eton and the like.
Re - OAS reform.
It has started - It's called MAID. Removed 16,500 mostly boomers in 2025 alone.
About 75 K since 2015
The economic incentives for Canadian federal and provincial governments to support MAiD expansion is too little discussed. The activists and pressure groups who keep talking about "rights" are just useful idiots.
The gangsters of the 1930s Murder Incorporated group must be turning over in their graves with envy. The MAIDerer group Dying with Dignity raised and spent in excess of $1 million in ads and publicity in the last year. (For more I recommend sub-stacker Kelsi Sheren). One of the spokespeople for DWD commented on the government decision to defer indefinitely the use of MAID in cases where suffering was solely due to mental illness, was a violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. I thought you had a right to life. But I guess that’s another American lie.
“With the right planning and help from someone like me, a 75-year-old couple can retain some OAS on a combined income of $370,000.”
That's a good trick. My wife and I are boomers whose combined dividend income ensures we never receive a dollar of OAS. That doesn't bother us: our financial security is beyond threatening without this superfluous bonus. Why would we begrudge 'our' OAS entitlement being allocated to seniors who actually need it, when we already have enough to have gotten both our daughters and their families into houses of their own, with no impact on mom and dad's lifestyle whatsoever? 'Someone like you'—what are you, a tax evasion specialist? How far ahead of the game do the financially fortunate have to be before they feel 'secure?' Your post leaves it unclear in which direction you envision OAS 'reform' ideally going.
Are you arguing with me or agreeing with me? I've been advocating OAS reform precisely because the current system allows affluent seniors to collect benefits they don't need.
As a CPA, I help people arrange their affairs within the law. That's tax planning, not tax evasion. The fact that the rules permit something doesn't mean I think the rules make sense.
Are you comfortable with the scenario I described? A 75-year-old couple with $370,000 in combined income retaining some OAS? And that's just the income visible on their personal tax returns. Factor in wealth and income accumulated or retained through corporations, trusts and estates, and their actual financial resources could be substantially greater.
That's precisely why OAS reform should consider a wealth test, or at least some mechanism for accounting for income and economic benefits enjoyed indirectly.
The question isn't whether someone can structure their affairs to collect OAS. It's whether taxpayers should be funding OAS payments to people who plainly don't need them.
OAS reform prioritization :
1) reduce the threshold at which clawback begins, maybe 60K,and that at which OAS is completely clawed back, maybe $90K. I'd have to build a model to figure out the exact thresholds to ensure it doesn't create discontinuities
2) base above thresholds on an average if several years income to reduce gaming
3) eliminate the extra amount introduced by Trudeau for those 75 and over
4) reduce indexing for a few years to put OAS back on trend. Trudeau increased amounts in excess of inflation
5) push eligibility to 67 or 68
That is one way. You could also own an investment corporation with a large tax paid shareholder loan and pay tax in the company and draw down the shareholder loan.
As a species, we secretly like rich people and wish to be them.
My goodness Martin, some of your post almost sounds genuine.
Then I look at your profile and see you subscribe to Conrad Black, Brian Lilley, Poilievre, and others. All spouting propaganda and lies.
So, I will have to read your comments with that in mind. That is to say you have an agenda, just simmering beneath your words. Rather than sound like a bombastic buffoon like Poilievre does, your post is a little more troubling, because it’s clear you are trying to cast aspersions on Carney.
Again, considering majority of your choice of subscriptions being the epitome of fake news, fake and rage posting outlets, and outright lies by the MAGA owned Hedgefund-backed Post Media outlets.
Is that an ad hominem argument or what!
Hmm. Well, I'm a boomer and I certainly don't support an increase in immigration. In fact, I don't support much of anything he's done. Which isn't much.
“It’s not quite so simple, but it’s true enough to note that Carney has both distanced himself from, and even dismantled, much of Justin Trudeau’s legacy. And in doing so, he has reaped political benefit.”
This statement is demonstrably false.
Canadians let Mark Carney change the filter, without changing the oil .
The vehicle is still a wreck.
Most commentators repeat the adage that government must be changed gradually, not radically.
Not a sentiment I agree with, but I think it undermines what Carney can do quickly.
The greatest impediment to change with the current Government, is the current Government.
Mark, I understand what you are saying. Yes, change is hard.
But this Government is slow-walking real, demonstrative change because 1/2 to 2/3 of the caucus is opposed to the changes being discussed.
I doubt that’s anymore true than saying most of the Republican Party is now MAGA. A lot of the support within caucus that Trudeau had was because it’s full of people who want power, not because they had any real investment in his ideology beyond it being popular. They were, and mostly still are, cowards who are just trying to keep their jobs.
I understand what you are saying, and I don’t disagree.
Many Republicans have left the Party since 2016.
In the U.S., there is far less “Leader-of-the-Party” pull through, in my opinion.
Yes, the caucus is full of grifters, charlatans, and ne’er-do-wells; but I disagree they are not ideologically captured.
Great post, friend.
“In 2015, Canada admitted 271,845 permanent residents.”
Last year, the number was 380,000.
The immigration level was not decreased at all, compared to previous levels over a longer term.
Canadians have been misled again, and will reward the same miscreant politicians by electing them again, and again, and again.
So, the entire premise of the essay is incorrect; the immigration levels have never returned to previous levels, so the Great Economic Savant- The Dithering Darling of Davos- cannot claim to be enhancing immigration numbers as they have never truly been reduced by a significant extent.
But the numbers are down from "catastrophic apocalyptic what-the-hell-are-they-doing!?" levels of 2021 to 2024 so we should be very very grateful.
Maybe. Another year or two of insanity might have created enough of a backlash to inoculate us against Carney's stealthier malice.
Call me a radical but I would rather the government focus on more housing to enable younger people to be able to afford a home instead of increasing the number of competitors to those homes.
Remigration is a much better idea, since it will increase wages and reduce taxes as well as reducing housing costs.
Sure, but if people are migrating here, what are the odds they are going to voluntarily leave?
Cut off benefits and social services, make it an offense for employers to hire them without a valid SIN, permanent ban on re-entry to Canada for anyone without a valid visa who doesn't check out on the way out create a hostile environment. Most will go voluntarily.
Even offering them a plane ticket home is worth it.
You are talking about two different classes of people here. For those here illegally (e.g., no visa, a tourist visa but working illegally, or the rare "refugee" whose "asylum" claim has been denied but he's still here) they should be deported under current procedures. No need to call it re-migration, voluntary or otherwise. It doesn't matter whether they want to leave or not. They shouldn't be here.
Getting people who are here legally to change their minds and out-migrate themselves is another thing altogether. One way would be to cancel TFW visas en masse and stop hearing asylum claims. Then the ex-holders and rejected claimants have to leave, and they become ineligible for free health care. For permanent residents ("landed immigrants"), they can still be deported at the pleasure of the Crown even if they haven't done anything wrong. Once their status is rescinded, they have to leave. So the government can re-migrate any number of non-citizens it likes.
Unfortunately many of these deportation orders issued now are being contested in Court and some federal Court judges are exceedingly sympathetic to immigrants and the diversity they represent, even ones the government really wants to deport for having committed serious crimes in Canada or who make bogus claims for asylum such as for being trans-gendered in the U.S. I can't see wholesale re-migration of people who haven't done anything wrong in Canada -- we just don't want them here anymore -- being upheld. People who are making a go of it in Canada probably wouldn't be persuaded to return to the old country just for a plane ticket. And the deadbeats probably find the social safety couch more comfortable here than back home.
Re-migration involves some nastiness. Canadians are "nice" but not really very kind. We could do it, but we'd have to really want to.
I think this is spot on. I like Jen's "we don't talk about Truuudough", but the man's actions still have consequences, one of which is killing any chance of a successor using immigration as a policy lever safely.
There are exceptions... it would probably be a safe move if every one of them was a family doctor starting a family practice clinic close to your home or workplace... but that's about it. Actions have consequences and the LPC trashed immigration... likely for a long time. And it was the LPC, not just Mr. unnamable, Mr. Carney's current crop of MPs all went along with it.
It's unfortunate, but it is what it is.
If the LPC wants to revive an immigration consensus, they probably need to put a tighter focus on language and cultural issues. And yes, that probably does mean a lot less "we'll coddle your lack of our languages" and more "you are not eligible unless you're already perfectly fluent". Think about it.. we provide voting assistance in more than two dozen languages other than English, French & indigenous languages... We gave voting rights to people who cannot even speak our common tongues.. how can you be part of our society if you can't even communicate with your fellow citizens properly?
It's bizarre.
And yes, it might also involve a lot more careful scrutiny of immigrants who come from parts of the world with completely incompatible social values. And yes, it might also mean inserting a delay between the right to live and work in Canada and put down roots and becoming a citizen. Currently the minimum time is three years. Is that enough time to assimilate someone into our culture? I mean.. I like a lot of countries, but truly integrating would take a lot longer than three years for any of them.
These are the consequences of the LPC getting so deeply, deeply unserious. They broke our trust on immigration and rebuilding that takes time and difficult actions.
Excellent points.
Very few will entertain a discussion about why multiculturalism doesn't work with cultures whose basic beliefs are antithetical to our own.
Or how all our beliefs about human rights, liberalism, and equality are simply a culture manifestation and how mass immigration from different cultures will eliminate them all.
Our economy now has two sectors: people who work at useful jobs and people whose income comes from liquidating and selling assets, private or public. Mass immigration suppresses wages and so harms the first group while benefiting the latter by reducing their cost of living.
The latter group are Carney's voters: boomers and broad public sector employees.
The only way immigration harms Carney is if outrage among those harmed builds to the point that the beneficiaries are carried along against their financial interests.
The second sector fits my economics prof’s definition of the “service economy” - people who earn a living from taking in each other’s washing. And let’s not forget entitlement hounds In Carney’s voter classes.
They mostly aren't even doing that. Given large deficits, most govt beneficiaries are simply being paid by rapidly increasing govt debt, and their "work", if any, is of little value. Retirees are doing nothing useful by definition.
Well gee, I like to think making intelligent comments here is useful! ;)
Sick burn! Mea culpa. Let's say "nothing valued in the market economy".
I think carney will likely get a couple years grace. One, increased immigration effects take time to show up. Two, as long as Trump is in office it’s difficult to imagine another party taking control of parliament in an election.
But I am in the camp of those Opposed to an increase in immigration. However, on a practical level, the woke policies in schools have created generations of kids not having their own kids and not getting married. As long as that’s happening, then immigration is necessary not only for limited growth, but for even maintaining the current population. That makes the immigration topic complicated because multigenerational Canadians find themselves in a position of becoming a minority, largely because of the decisions they’ve made and the things their own children have been taught. And that is an issue.
But I don’t think maintaining our population via immigration is the answer. I think it’s less fear around climate change and humans killing the planet. More values continuing to be shared around family and the value of children. We’ve stopped valuing children in the same way. I know some will agree with me, but take a look at birth rates and see where population actually grows. It’s immigration more than Canadian births. I view that as a problem.
Creating an environment where young people are discouraged and prevented from forming families and having children is perhaps the most destructive cruelty perpetrated by our current society. Most young Canadians still theoretically want their own children, many of them are just at a loss as to how to make it happen, or how to manage it financially and psychologically.
> However, on a practical level, the woke policies in schools have created generations of kids not having their own kids and not getting married.
While I'd agree those policies have negative effects, that's not what's causing drops in fertility. (We know this because you see it in other places).
But you know what's common to all those places? Higher costs on marriage age people and higher costs of raising kids. And that fits with my experience... most people I know say "expensive" when the subject of kids comes up. And surveys continuously show that people have fewer kids then they say they want to have.
If you make something expensive, people have less of it.
I dislike coronated political leaders. If Carney wins a Nobel, a lot of heads will immediately blow up.
You must accept the wisdom of your betters.
The establishment has spoken. The great saviour saved a lot of wealthy insiders' bacon. The opposition made promises too far outside the desires of the managed state, would have made too many changes that would hurt established interests, so were successfully cast through a relentless propaganda campaign as an unacceptable choice, beyond the pale.
Those who screech this or that nitpick are just admitting that they swallowed it. Truth is, there shouldn't even BE a Liberal Party after what Trudeau did.
But we don't get to choose in this country, the choice is made for us. He might very well get the Nobel Prize. The establishment rewards their own.
Another in a long sequence of stellar posts, Mr. M.
Glad someone appreciates my frustrated ramblings. Cheers :)
Lol.. and his name rhymes with Drumpf.
"How the heck did that guy get a Nobel... he doesn't even have to whine and pretend that he won after extorting one from a lady whose country he invaded! It's not fair!".
Nobel *peace* prizes are absurd. Henry Kissenger, Barrack Obama, Yasser Arafat? Good grief, those are stupid choices. But it's just pathetic to be thirsty for one.
Rich are gonna rich.
Sean Fraser as Attorney General! Sad!! The guy who turned our passports into a colouring book for kids on those long flights.
And that's probably the least fucked up thing he did. He was in charge of immigration from 2021 to 2023. He should be working at McDonald's but not trusted near the deep fryer out of fear he'll burn the place down, with a resume like that.
👏👏👏
Carney walked out on a trade deal that would likely have limited the damage to Canadian jobs.
The following is from Blacklock's Reporter this morning where they quote the labour department who wrote the following in a Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement.
"Foreign tariffs have already significantly affected Canadian industries reliant on trade with the United States including lumber, steel and aluminum, automobiles and agriculture,” said the notice. A jump in EI claims was “disproportionately higher in tariff impacted sectors” including 44 percent higher among steelworkers in Northern Ontario. “The Employment Insurance region of Oshawa, for example, saw a 400 percent increase in regular claims,” it said.
“United States tariffs could place approximately 87,000 Canadian jobs at risk including roughly 52,000 direct exporter jobs and approximately 35,000 jobs linked to suppliers and service industries,” said the Analysis Statement.
The 87,000 figure was sourced with approval from an August 26 story in the news site The Hub, “New U.S. Tariffs On $28 Billion In Canadian Goods Put 87,000 Jobs At Risk, Economist Estimates.” The article quoted University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe, a former Privy Council consultant."
As the number of previously trained, hard working Canadians who are forced out of work grows, they too will join an unemployment line that is being filled by too much immigration.
> Carney walked out on a trade deal that would likely have limited the damage to Canadian jobs.
In the short term in exchange for long term damage.
The US wanted to control our ability to make trade agreements with other countries. That's an obvious "we'll stop punching you as long as you lie down and let us put a knife to your throat". That's suicide.
But yes, you're right... it would have helped us in the short term.
The more we delay a selttlement the more I feel that PM Carney is actually in agreement with President Trump's objective of shifting government revenues more towards tariffs and less towards income taxes and consumption taxes. The more a settlement is delayed and people adapt to the new regime the more likely it will be on permanent. I see the elbozoery and French Language histrionic heroics (😆) as being a smokescreen (fog of the trade war?) to hide what will be the new reality. Even the PM I believe admitted any new agreement would not get rid of tariffs. Just my .05s worth (loonie's worth in 2026).
Besides the economic arguments over immigration, Canada needs to revisit official multiculturalism. It seems at odds with both the human nature to socialize and the desired outcome of a shared national purpose. Multiculturalism, i.e. incentivized non-assimilation, only benefits politicians who can more easily target groups, and community leaders' need for emoyment.
Naw. He is The One. He can do whatever he wants
There’s an interesting article by Lorne Gunter in the Edmonton Journal (Oct 3rd) that suggests Carney really hasn’t reduced immigration as he has claimed. Worth a read
"The poll shows 52 per cent of Canadians in favour of the country accepting fewer people with 35 per cent content with the current level. That’s very few leftover to fall in the “controlled increase” camp."
The controlled increase Carney spoke of was population. You're conflating it with a controlled increase to immigration levels. Note that the 35% refers to "maintain current immigration levels", not current population.
Agreed. Immigration helps prop up real estate values and confers leverage to public sector employees who can build the narrative that demand for their services exceeds supply
It's hard to know how to react to Carney's statement without any details. The Harper-era immigration system also led to an increase in Canada's population, but at a rate and with a set of criteria that resulted in widespread acceptance before Trudeau blew it up. Carney's clearly indicating that he's not going to go to the near-zero immigration approach advocated by some people, but I suspect that block of voters wasn't in Carney's column anyway.
Carney's taking a risk floating statements like this without details. People might be willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for now, but he's also potentially giving opponents a blank canvas on which they can project extremely negative possibilities. That could turn public opinion against Carney, and a more experienced politician should understand that it's dangerous to let your opponents define the terms of the debate.
I don’t disagree with what you’re saying, but I think not being an experienced politician is actually Carney’s strength, even though he’s had to stick handle a fair bit in prior roles. Having someone else erroneously define the terms of debate is something I think a capable person could easily deal with.