30 Comments
User's avatar
Darcy Hickson's avatar

There is lots to wish for as BC voters sort out the mess they have been dealt by a cynical Premier hiding behind Trump to extend his mandate.

As a passive observer from afar, I hope that the voters coalesce around the Conservatives with a solid mandate to clean house and bring some fiscal sanity and public safety back into vogue. If BC citizens can stomach the challenge ahead then there is hope for the rest of us too.

Gerald Pelchat's avatar

Canadians on the Federal level have been told, ( and appear to have accepted) that some hard times are ahead. A perfect time for a Provincial party to ride the same sentiment and get some reality back into Provincial politics.

John Hilton's avatar

I think appears is an appropriate qualifier. No actual painful decision that affects a significant proportion of Canadians has been made yet and we still don’t know if the bond issues that are hitting the US will affect us.

George Skinner's avatar

I'm also hoping for an NDP defeat, but I'm a bit apprehensive about how the Conservatives would perform in government. They started this election mid-way through an intraparty civil war between a populist faction and a centrist faction, and the party itself is a somewhat undefined agglomeration of right of centre elements that only came together in the lead up to the previous provincial election.

Best case is that they realize they're a coalition that's been elected with a mandate to get the province righted after years of cumulative NDP failures. Worst case is something like the Alberta UCP since 2019, with factions fighting and more extreme elements dragging the government into niche partisan priorities.

Darcy Hickson's avatar

That's a fair assessment and a fair concern. The BC voters seem to be ready to take a chance on the ambiguity and perhaps the voters may come to accept that nothing can be worse than what they have now.

The other interesting dynamic is the broad spectrum of left wing ideologies that are anchored in the NDP that are becoming unwieldy. Eby was forced to abandon promises to amend DRIPA due to an inability to secure the support within his Caucus. (So we are told).

John Hilton's avatar

Fights tend to disappear once in power.

George Skinner's avatar

One killer issue that went unmentioned is that people are unhappy with BC’s adoption of UNDRIP under the NDP, the lack of visibility about the deals being struck between the NDP and First Nations, and an increasingly impression that the NDP government also hasn’t been honest. This issue has been rippling through rural areas in BC for some years (although some issues fall under federal jurisdiction.). The court ruling that raised questions of title over homes in Richmond brought the issue home to urban areas, and the NDP seems paralyzed by their internal politics.

Matthew Ewanchuk's avatar

What government is honest? The Liberals had the triple delete scandal to which the NDP upped by neutering FOI laws.

The BC NDP should have been better prepared but the fact is that Eby is not popular even within his own party.

He couldn't even win the leadership content without help from the party's old boys network and he also lost the last provincial election to Pollievre who wasn't even running.

UNDRIP has not been a major issue in the campaign that I've heard about. A lot of those problems stem from the actions of politicians pre-confederation.

The Massey tunnel comes up a lot in Richmond and Delta. The bridge wasn't popular but swapping it to build a tunnel that will arrive a decade late at 3X the cost is terrible.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Rob Shaw writes well.

That was a stellar essay.

It was loaded with facts, balanced appropriately, and layered with opinion and context.

It was a pleasure to read.

IceSkater40's avatar

I read an article shortly after the writ was dropped on Bc that said snap elections when the public doesn’t want one often don’t favor the incumbent. Seems Eby is discovering that and I find it hilarious to watch. Not much has changed in the last 2 years and the last election was pretty tight. It’s about that time where BC voters cast out the ruling party - it’s funny that Eby’s attempt to take advantage of a weak conservative party could spectacularly backfire.

(I know he claims the election is about Trump, but let’s be real - the conservatives were in disarray and that had to be a giant factor. I don’t believe for a minute that something significant had changed with the threat from Trump and that the conservative disarray had no influence at all.)

Tsur's avatar
Oct 7Edited

Maybe I have Eby math wrong, but a $0.10/litre cut in excise taxes yields $20 a tank savings for those with a 200 litre tank. If you have the average gas tank size (across cars/SUVs/minivans/pick-up trucks of say 65 litres) then you get $6.50 in savings. Just because Eby said it, doesn't make it correct.

PT's avatar

Math has never been the NDP's strong suite.

John Hilton's avatar

Might as well say 200 dollar savings per fill up. Why not?

KRM's avatar

Now imagine if every media source other than the National Post and a handful of kooky right-wing 'influencers' was going balls to the wall emergency attack mode against the BC Conservative Party like they do against the Federal party. Carrying every NDP attack, taking Eby's Trump threat boogeyman narrative seriously, dismissing the Conservative leader as unacceptable/untrustworthy/extreme/MAGA/weak all at the same time. I think the race would be going very differently.

Instead we get detached bemusement pretty much across the spectrum about how the BC NDP stepped in it by calling a stupid election, and those BC Conservatives are ok I guess, not really sure but whatever.

This used to be the media default in all elections. Call out the scandals and the stupidity, endorse or criticize specific policies, but accept that really any party is within the realm of acceptability to form government. Stark stark contrast with how the media treats federal elections where it's basically "Liberals or the world ends".

In fairness, the BC Conservative party does not seem to have made personally financially ruining every journalist in the country a central plank in their platform however.

John Hilton's avatar

The last paragraph that you wrote is key. The federal Conservatives are so busy sniffing each others farts in closed rooms that they can’t see how stupid their approach was.

KRM's avatar

All media in this country should have all funding pulled, including the CBC. The approach was philosophically correct.

The party, unfortunately, put philosophical correctness over not completely hobbling themselves in an election where they ran opposed by anything other than a despised Liberal leader with a -40 approval rating.

Maybe make media defunding part of the real "hidden agenda" though at this point a CPC leader would have to probably send secret self-incriminating photos to CBC News to back promises not to pull funding if elected.

John Hilton's avatar

Just play the game. It’s not that hard. Rather than call everyone who covers you assholes, be conciliatory and give interviews that reach the voters you need to get.

Pierre already had his twitter/social media crowd. He needed everyone else and he shut off all opportunities to get them to please voters he already had in his pocket. That’s dumb politics.

KRM's avatar

Once he committed to pulling all the subsidies and "defund the CBC" no amount of (probably unfriendly) interviews would have changed much.

The problem wasn't so much that he didn't get positive coverage, it's that 80% of the country's media outlets became unofficial members of the Mark Carney campaign team and did their absolute best to pave over any accountability or connection to the Trudeau decade of disaster, in an all out push to save their income.

Kary Troyer's avatar

A surprise election call brings surprises! Note to Eby: fix what ails you, your party, and BC first and then call an election. This election has a bunch of things weird. Surrey mayor candidates saying they will build hospitals, and a wannabe premier saying he will add police in towns, Eby saying he will tame Trump. Mr. Shaw is correct - the voters aren't sure why they are voting on an election about nothing and there most likely will be presenting BC with a government that is weaker, less organized, and power will lie with a few culture warriors. Just what we need for what's happening next door in Alberta and how to instill confidence in Mr. Carney that we have our act together. Not to mention that the civic election is on at the same time.

sji's avatar

"brushing aside the fact Pattison has made the largest single medical donation in Canadian history at $75-million towards Eby’s new St. Paul’s Hospital in Vancouver."

THIS! speaks to, rather captures, the weakness of Eby's character, the chaos and abuse his ego foists on our Province. That he would parrot, and butcher the nationalist sentiment, the anti-fascist rhetoric as awkwardly as he did only to justify his poorly judged personal power grab was low... so low. So scummy. He deserves a historic drubbing as coda to his trail of lies, manipulations, and destruction.

sji's avatar

"eyebrow-raising miscalculations..."

Maybe the most flattering summary possible of Eby's tenure as leader.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

A bit ridiculous to scoff at groomers when it is quite clear that the biggest school massacre in BC history was recent and literally committed by a victim of a trans groomer.

Sean Cummings's avatar

If the NDP loses this is the biggest self-own in recent memory.

dennis mcconaghy's avatar

Any NDP government is an insult to rational governance.

Eby one of the worst.

We soon find out how stupid British Colombia actually is.

Perhaps a Conservative government will restore private property in BC?

Davey J's avatar

Restore private property? Nothing was lost on that front. The Cowichan and any other land claim is not directed at fee simple private property owners, and never will be. This is one of the unserious things Conservatives say to try to rage bait for votes. The only reason there is uncertainty is because groups are using it as a tool to smear a sitting government. The Cowichan won because that land was taken from them in a fraudulent transaction by a BC government employee over a century ago, and they wanted the part that the BC Government owned and compensation for the rest. It was not because of any attacks on private property rights. And they still would have won this case even if DRIPA did not exist.

John Hilton's avatar

Well, the banks are acting like it is. It’s the BC government that is frantically trying to pretend it isn’t.

If not, why appeal the decision?

Leslie MacMilla's avatar

>The Cowichan and any other land claim is not directed at fee simple private property owners, and never will be.

The first part of that is narrow opinion (that relies heavily on what "directed" means) and the second is a broad prediction. Both rely on what our adversaries, the Cowichans whose interests don't align with ours, might decide to do or not do at some time in the future.

If there is going to be "compensation", that money still comes from the residents of British Columbia and of Canada and most of that money will come from fee-simple landowners given the distribution of tax-paying. It's not a case of "the government" using dollars from some divine source to make amends painlessly.

Clay Eddy Arbuckle's avatar

Wow! Great article,thank you Rob. I’m keeping my fingers crossed