Tammy Robert: The NDP has to pick a leader, and a direction
The cast of characters vying for the NDP's leadership demonstrates just how unresolved the party’s identity crisis really is.
By: Tammy Robert
The New Democratic Party stands at a crossroads.
Again.
It feels different this time. Almost like it’s about to determine whether it can or even should survive as a meaningful force in Canadian politics.
This past weekend’s Saskatchewan NDP convention in Saskatoon provided a fascinating window into this transformation and the growing influence of western Canada’s political machinery on its federal parent’s future. With more than 600 delegates in attendance and a new, rather odd mantra of “government-in-waiting” since their near-miss in the 2024 provincial election, the Saskatchewan NDP is reportedly enjoying a surge in donations. It also seems to be displaying something like the desire to live, a feeling which it has not seen from its membership in years.
But while some provincial NDP parties are showing signs of health, things are much more uncertain at the federal level.
As the federal NDP prepares for its March 2026 leadership convention following its worst electoral defeat in history, only two clear figures have emerged to embody competing visions for the future: Edmonton MP Heather McPherson, the NDP establishment’s standard-bearer, and climate activist Avi Lewis, the progressive left’s chosen champion. Together with B.C. labour leader Rob Ashton, and Tanille Johnston, a municipal elected official from Vancouver Island and the first Indigenous woman to seek the NDP leadership, all four declared federal NDP leadership candidates campaigned hard at the Saskatchewan convention. But Lewis and McPherson seem the early favourites, and it’s not close.
Saskatchewan is playing an outsized role in the race. Three of the four federal leadership candidates have campaign managers with significant Saskatchewan ties, including McPherson advisor George Soule, a former Saskatchewan NDP chief of staff, and Ashton campaign manager Deanna Ogle, a former provincial party vice-president who quit in protest of what she claimed was the “undermining” of then-provincial leader Ryan Meili.
The race itself is critical for the future of the party. In a recent piece for The Line, Mitch Heimpel nailed the broader picture when he asked, “Are they the party of the union hall or the faculty lounge? Because trying to be both stopped working.”
That’s the central tension threading through this entire leadership race, and if anything, its cast of characters demonstrates just how unresolved the party’s identity crisis really is.
McPherson, surrounded by influential advisers including former Alberta premier Rachel Notley and veteran strategist Brian Topp, represents continuity with the NDP’s traditional labour-focused, western Canadian foundation. McPherson’s political trajectory is a textbook example of traditional NDP values translated into modern electoral success. The 52-year-old Edmonton native has won three consecutive elections in Alberta’s most progressive federal riding. She even supported the controversial Trans Mountain pipeline expansion — a position that puts her highly at odds with environmental activists in her party, but aligns with western Canada’s economic realities.
If Ashton drops off the ballot early in the process, campaign insiders have indicated to me that they feel his support would flow to McPherson, further consolidating the western vote.
Lewis, grandson of NDP founder David Lewis and husband to author Naomi Klein, embodies the party’s desire to capture the imagination of urban progressives and young voters who view climate action as the defining issue of their generation. The 57-year-old filmmaker and climate activist entered politics as an outsider, losing consecutive federal campaigns in two of British Columbia’s wealthier ridings before positioning himself as a leadership contender. His Dipper pedigree runs deep but his approach represents a sharp departure from his family’s pragmatic political tradition. His collaboration with pop culture political figures like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez positions him as a face of international youth progressive activism.
For young NDPers, who view incremental change as insufficient to address anything right now, Lewis offers the promise of the transformational politics they feel are necessary to meet the scale of today’s geopolitical challenges. But his inexperience shows; reports from convention attendees say that as Lewis made his way through the convention centre, as part of his spiel he highlighted his co-authorship of the Leap Manifesto as evidence of his ability to build consensus.
That’s stunning. He was speaking to members of a provincial party that nearly imploded in part over that manifesto. Has he forgotten?
When asked, Lewis also stated, from the front of the room, that he doesn’t support the mission of Reclaim the NDP — a fledgling project urging NDP members to reroute donations away from the federal party and back into the grassroots engine of local electoral districts.
The geographic and demographic tensions within the NDP’s federal leadership race reflect broader challenges facing centre-left parties across Western democracies. What are they for? Who do they serve? The federal party’s challenge lies in reconciling western pragmatism (McPherson) against the expectations of eastern urban progressives (Lewis) who view the NDP as insufficiently radical compared to grassroots movements on climate change, housing, and economic inequality elsewhere.
This tension reflects a deeper truth about western Canadian political culture that all candidates will need to navigate. Western Canadian New Democrats tend to function more like tree-hugging, somewhat schizophrenic conservatives: environmentally conscious but fiscally pragmatic, suspicious of Ottawa but committed to activist government, progressive on social issues but protective of resource-based economic opportunities.
Some might consider these positions conflicting. Hypocritical, even. But it is the party, as it exists today. The choice facing New Democrats will answer a fundamental question about the party’s purpose in contemporary Canadian politics. Retreating to its Western Canadian roots and focusing on practical opposition work seems like the more plausible pathway, but if there’s one thing Canadian Dippers know how to do well, it’s aim high.
The answers to these questions will be delivered, not in March 2026’s NDP convention hall, but in the years of political combat that follow on Parliament Hill. What we know for sure is that the New Democratic Party that emerges from this leadership contest will look much different from the one that entered it, whether as a renewed political force capable of challenging government… or as a cautionary tale about the perils of ideological complexity, if not confusion, in modern-day Canada.
Tammy Robert is a Saskatchewan-based public relations expert, political blogger, and commentator known for her analysis of Saskatchewan politics and governance. She is the author of Our Sask and has contributed commentary to CBC, Maclean’s, and various media and publications.
The Line is entirely reader and advertiser funded — no federal subsidy for us! If you value our work, have already subscribed, and still worry about what will happen when the conventional media finishes collapsing, please make a donation today. Please note: a donation is not a subscription, and will not grant access to paywalled content. It’s just a way of thanking us for what we do. If you’re looking to subscribe and get full access, it’s that other blue button!
The Line is Canada’s last, best hope for irreverent commentary. We reject bullshit. We love lively writing. Please consider supporting us by subscribing. Please follow us on social media! Facebook x 2: On The Line Podcast here, and The Line Podcast here. Instagram. Also: TikTok. BlueSky. LinkedIn. Matt’s Twitter. The Line’s Twitter.Jen’s Twitter. Contact us by email: lineeditor@protonmail.com.
Lost in what otherwise is a fine article is any reference to the modern NDPs affectations with pro Palestinian politics. Both McPherson and Lewis' views on this are well known and will also closely align with the views of young people who get their cues from TikTok and faculty members across many university campuses.
Viewing Israel as a colonial power imposing its oversized will against a weak Gaza society turns history and logic upside down. It's dangerous territory and the front runners need to provide clarity to the Jews in Canada who are fearful for their lives and also to those of us who can't believe the overt antisemitism that is bubbling out into the open.
Canadian journalists are prone to be very antagonistic towards "right wing populism", which is firmly rooted in western Canadian culture. Left unspoken is the "left wing populism" of western Canada which through the odd change of garments became the NDP.
As the author notes, the NDP was also built upon prairie pragmatism that dreamed big but realized that incremental change would keep the broader public on side. The radicals who wanted everything NOW would have to put some water in their wine.
The current leadership aspirants could do themselves a big favour and adapt a pragmatic approach that identifies life for ordinary people and addresses their concerns in ways that are tangible and meaningful. The NDP went all in on identity politics, which creates a divisive hierarchy of privilege that is the antithesis of equality and fairness for all. As it stands now, the NDP is not interested in fairness and has taken hostility towards men to new heights with quota targets that discourage men from participating in the leadership race. Petty, shortsighted and arrogant.