113 Comments
User's avatar
Matt Gurney's avatar

Reminder that my patience with petty bullshit in the comments is exhausted. Behave or be banned.

Jo's avatar

Hope your family is doing ok. Been sending all my prayers for resilience and recovery.

lrhepworth@gmail.com's avatar

Great podcast. Love Jen’s enthusiasm and agree with all her points about Daniele Smith, except that I have never found her to have any redeeming qualities. Nothing good can come from this referendum. She is mistaken if she thinks there is a million people in this province wanting to separate.

Roki Vulović's avatar

Polling literally shows there are. There is no use in denial of reality.

lrhepworth@gmail.com's avatar

Since the separatists are making it clear that they are meeting with “US officials”, I find it hard to believe that there are that many people who would believe it would be a good thing to be taken over by the US.

Roki Vulović's avatar

I doubt Albertans and Canadians would be asked for their opinion to be honest.

lrhepworth@gmail.com's avatar

Really hard to follow your logic on this … but whatever.

Sheila's avatar

Until we have a referendum Smith is best saying exactly what’s she’s currently saying. Her job is to defend Alberta, and right now that means walking a fine line. There are some pretty sane people, and there are some absolute nutters in the separatist tent, she has to steer clear of the nutters, and shes always said a sovereign Alberta inside Canada is the goal. This is what Quebec already has. I think she needs to stay the course.

raymond's avatar

Yeah, my feel is that Danielle just does not want to be involved in it, and staying far away from this. Then when the referendum goes one way or another, she'll declare victory, and go with the referendum results

Lois's avatar

Please chill, lest your level of emotion push people even further into the "religious like" fervor that you intended to decry. The high level of fervor on both sides is concerning for our society's future.

Here's what could be considered. 1 - Relatively few people are really engaged in the fervor about the potential referendum. It's not good to pump up those that are, as Jen points out.

2. Not much that happens in AB matters as much as we think. The US people visited 3 times backed off when they realized that someone cared about visits that to them were possibly routine. Investors are influenced by certainty and the federal government provides way more lack of certainty than even a separate Alberta could produce.

3. Danielle's statement is enough for me and many people who are not responding to others' emotion. I don't want the UCP to implode because the attitude/emotion levels among NDP supporters really concern me - talk about fervor and making things personal!

4. Policy losses can be predictive and can hurt people in ways that attitude cannot fix. That's not an excuse for forever anger, but those losses hurt a lot of people.

Sheila's avatar

Exactly, unfortunately Ottawa HAS created an insane level of regulation and uncertainty, and Carney has done nothing to lessen that. He could act, but instead he’s talking out of both sides of his mouth, we know he’s a net zero nutter, and that he’s given BC and FN a veto on any pipelines thru BC, then creates an MOU barely worth the paper its written on.

Roki Vulović's avatar

Let's not forget that Ottawa is literally conducting a gun ban and buyback.

It isn't like Ottawa and it's foreign culture isn't driving all this.

Jerry Grant's avatar

Wouldn't it be nice to have a register of foreign influencers?

Clarke's avatar

Matt, a distinct pleasure to hear your voice on the podcast again. Welcome back!

Roki Vulović's avatar

The Alberta separatists are counting on folks like Jen gaslighting Albertans grievances like an abusive spouse to built up their numbers. Separatists are I'm sure sharing this podcast far and wide.

Jen uses a lot of the same talking points that I remember the Serbs using against the Slovenians and Croatians. 30 years later and those countries are much, much better ahead for choosing independence and to join the EU.

As for economic pain for Alberta, that makes no sense. Separatism is about making Alberta more economically friendly and getting closer to the US and it's awesomely dynamic economy. The market knows that.

As for Alberta's place in Canada and the so called loser energy and whining, Quebec has done the exact same thing and came out like winners. A big part of Alberta separatism in fact is based around Ontario and Quebec being first among equals and taking advantage of Alberta.

As for the supposed advantages of Canada, Canada is a country in decline and a culture that is so deathly afraid of risk that it is allowing the rest of the world to treat it as a pawn while we become poorer. Why would Albertans want that sinking ship? And bonus. It gets to support cashed up boomers in Eastern Canada who never got the memo that the state can't afford free everything for them without their grandkids becoming poorer.

I'm a "soft federalist" because Confederation is like a marriage and no one should ever take it for granted. But man if Jen is characteristic of the federalists we are going to see a lot of emotional abuse, and unlike 1995 there is no media filter.

sji's avatar

I think you've missed the central premise of Jenn's article. Maybe you prefer to argue about your points instead...?

Roki Vulović's avatar

Are you sure you listened to the same podcast all the people who liked my post and myself did?

KayDee's avatar

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 to Jen for calling out Smith's treasonous BS. She obviously values power over ANYTHING ELSE!

The same applies to every one of her spineless UCP MLAs!

Their lack of voice/action is unethical and borders on fraud!

JoanneTL's avatar

I'm only halfway through but GO JEN!! Love it. Okay, back to it now.

Jerry Grant's avatar

20 minutes of Jen ranting about how much she hates 30% of Albertans. Is The Line still independent? It sure sounds like you are carrying Carney's water again.

B–'s avatar

I fast-forwarded after 10 🤣

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 31
Comment removed
Jerry Grant's avatar

It turned out to be 40 minutes of vitriol that could have been expressed in 2.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 31
Comment removed
Roki Vulović's avatar

Yeah, I will unsubscribe if this continues. But calling people who disagree with you losers isn't what I pay money for.

Claiming that the UCP doesn't have a mandate to extend democracy to a referendum is an opinion, a very elitist and revisionist opinion (she ran on increasing direct democracy literally) but not one I actually want to promote with my money.

Crankypants's avatar

Every f****** word of Jen’s rant…made my heart sing! Truth…

Neil's avatar

Jen your rants about separation being rural is only partially correct. You make it sound like we are rubes that have been duped and that is wrong. The reasons for seperation are many but it comes down to lack of political power at federal level so they want to govern themselves. Rural people will still have that same problem with Calgary and Edmonton if separation occured. I don't think we would got thru all that grief to just be back where we started.

Roki Vulović's avatar

Nevermind that the separatists filled the Big 4 Building in Central Calgary this week.

Neil's avatar

The big 4 is minutes from downtown Calgary

Roki Vulović's avatar

Literally walking distance from downtown.

But if you listen to the media, separatism is just a movement of rural cranks.

Neil's avatar

My point was exactly that. They view rural people as backward and gullible, but most of my neighbours are fairly politically aware. one of them is even my local MP

Sean Cummings's avatar

For me, the National Energy Program is embedded in the cells of everyone who lived through it. That frames the mindset of Gen Xers and Boomers. I have yet to meet someone who lived through the NEP who is not resentful toward Ottawa. Generationally, I would imagine as well. Then we get a decade's worth of preening narcissistic ass who wanted to kill the province's oil industry which bankrolls half the country. He was never called on that poisonous divisiveness in the news from what I could tell.

I'd like to mention that separatists are still our fellow citizens. We need to find a way forward that keeps Alberta and possibly Saskatchewan in confederation. A pipeline? I dunno. Maybe shift three of the four PEI seats for a population of a mere 180,000 to Alberta. Constitutional changes are going to have to happen to keep Alberta and everything could blow up.

I've seen the stats - around 30% support until you explain what they might lose, then it goes to 16%. That doesn't mean they have decided against separation. We have to get to the table and we have to hear each side out like the nice people Canadians are supposed to be.

One of three support the idea of an independent Alberta. That's over a million people in a province of 4.8 million.

That is what's called a movement.

I absolutely agree the CPC needs to catch up with reality, but it needs to be extended to those opposing separation because this isn't going away. It's just not. Calling them traitors and seditionist and treacherous means those folks need to face reality.

The minute Trump says he recognizes an independent Alberta, it's over.

These are dark times. Things change when dark times fall on a country and its people. We are absolutely living in anything can happen day, every day.

Once again, I think we need a national unity coalition government and soon.

This is not going away.

B–'s avatar

I don't blame those Albertans for wanting to separate. The rest of the country taunted and maligned Albertans for decades. Someone needs to look at the root causes here. Albertans aren't a bunch of overly sensitive whiners. As a British Columbian, I am absolutely appalled and angry about how BC has treated Alberta over the last 10 years, if not more. BC won't do well if Alberta ever leaves. We've mismanaged our province's resources and social programs for far too long. No wonder Eby is afraid.

Roki Vulović's avatar

As long as Quebec is rewarded by its own separatism, even having 1/3 of Supreme Court judges reserved for them, Western Canada is a sucker.

Jerry Grant's avatar

"I have yet to meet someone who lived through the NEP who is not resentful toward Ottawa." I still refuse to buy gas at Petro-Canada.

Jerry Grant's avatar

"The minute Trump says he recognizes an independent Alberta, it's over." Similarly, the moment Carney announces a pipeline and an exemption to the tanker ban, it's over.

B–'s avatar

I dunno. With the Liberal Party, announcements are usually only announcements.

Jerry Grant's avatar

You are right. He's made those announcements already.

Gaz's avatar

When Quebec leaves confederation the Alberta Separatist movement dies. Efforts to see them out the door will have greater returns than waiting for the penny to drop in Alberta.

Vive le Québec libre !

Mike Grosz's avatar

Jen. From a fellow Albertan. You nailed it. Thanks for articulating my feelings so perfectly.

Jo's avatar
Jan 31Edited

Canada is built to serve the middle. It’s systemic and the disconnect will worsen as people and wealth moves west. The evolution of Canada ends with massive systemic changes or dissolution. Right now any expressed concerns are met with ‘oh, you’re just dumb and racist.’

Examples not talked of, but significant: Bilingual requirements means there are very limited numbers of westerners in meaningful positions in the federal government and judicial appointments. Most of federal government located in a Montreal-Toronto bubble. This is huge for government policy, beyond electoral politics. Another: A 2022 review of seats in parliament establishing a floor of 70 seats in Quebec means less proportional weight of seats in BC, Ontario and Alberta. Thats electorally significant.

Canada is built so the west can’t win. It is designed this way. It is disingenuous (and intellectually lazy) to say, ‘just fucking win.’

SimulatedKnave's avatar

The bilingual requirements affect literally everyone who isn't in Quebec (and to a slightly extent New Brunswick), and are hardly an issue unique to Alberta. It would not be difficult for Alberta to get widespread support for some kind of action - if they tried. Literally every province except Quebec has that problem (which, to be frank, is more a problem that we do a terrible job teaching kids in this country French).

Unfortunately a decent chunk of the population of the country is in the Montreal-Toronto bubble, so it is unsurprising a lot of federal resources end up there. On top of that, literally every country has this problem. Alberta has this problem provincially.

Alberta currently has more MPs per person than Quebec does (barely, but still). You are not underrepresented except maybe at the Senatorial level, and then only because Quebec and Atlantic Canada are overrepresented.

George Skinner's avatar

I think the separatist movement is inextricably linked with anxiety over the oil industry. When Alberta is in an oil boom, lots of people benefit tremendously. My brother has related stories of pleading with high school kids in his rural district to stay in school and get their high school diploma even though dropping out could mean pulling down a 6 figure income immediately. Alberta in a boom has been one of the last places where a guy with a strong back willing to work can earn a truly lucrative livelihood.

There’s been two big booms, in the ‘70s and then from the late ‘90s until 2014. Each time the end of the boom has been attributed to malign actions by the federal government and the rest of Canada. The boom that ended in the early ‘80s was blamed on the National Energy Plan, which was an egregious piece of legislation. The boom that ended in 2014 was blamed on the failure to build pipelines, and later the fixation on reducing carbon emissions.

In both cases, there’s truth to the accusations. They tend to overlook the bigger global picture: oil prices collapses in the ‘80s; the run -up in prices in the ‘70s was due to factors like the Arab oil embargo in response to the Yom Kippur war, the Iranian Revolution, and American price control policies that throttled their own production. The oil price collapse in 2014 was similar: overproduction, a drop in demand, and an effort by OPEC to squeeze out competition from ore expensive producers. The broader trends were probably going to end the booms one way or another; the separatists want to imagine that the good times would’ve kept on rolling excel for those scummy politicians in Ottawa and people in the rest of Canada who wanted to squelch Alberta prosperity out of jealousy and avarice.

I remember the bumper stickers in the early ‘90s: “Lord, give me another boom and this time I won’t piss it away!” Well, there was another one and it ended too. Maybe not quite so catastrophically, although I know of friends who committed suicide when their businesses and livelihoods collapsed. The problem is that even though Alberta oil production is higher today than in 2014, the demand is starting to decline and the same secular trends towards automation and higher productivity are eliminating those lucrative jobs for guys without post -secondary education. Alberta independence won’t impact the broader global trends.

Jesse's avatar

Global peak oil, whenever that comes, is going to be fun times.

But, on the economic front, being a province within Canada is an insurance policy against that.

George Skinner's avatar

Yup - Alberta was an economic basket case before oil was struck in Leduc in 1948. The Great Depression and the dust bowl hit really hard, and Alberta was home to “Bible Bill” Eberhart and his “social credit” ideology. The oil industry required a lot of work and an increasingly skilled workforce, not just sticking a pipe in the ground and counting the money rolling in. Alberta worked hard to exploit that opportunity, but it’s still good fortune to have discovered such a resource.

Crankypants's avatar

Let’s not forget there was a good deal of federal, Ontario as well as Alberta public investment to get the oilsands operational.

Roki Vulović's avatar

So what? There was a great deal of federal, Alberta and Ontario investment in the Quebec aerospace industry but they don't get the same pishback

Jerry Grant's avatar

Who is paying into that insurance policy? Alberta, British Columbia, and Saskatchewan. The rest of the provinces are tanking.

Gaz's avatar

In the previous podcast Ms. Gerson correctly suggested the media give the Alberta Independence movement a pass. There is nothing new, other than Mr. Eby reading last year's news, so no reason to listen to the podcast.

"The Québec Government Office in Washington oversees Québec's bilateral relations with the United States Federal Government". Why should Alberta be different?

Please remember, Brian Mulroney brought the, to be, Bloc Québécois into Parliament.

"René Lévesque's memory will unite us all this weekend. He was the one who led Quebecers to realize they had the inalienable right to decide their own destiny." Perhaps the same will be said of Ms. Smith.

Asymmetric federalism will end, or Confederation will.