I couldn’t agree more. Love the CFL’s incredible culture, on display at every Grey Cup. I did see Argo and Als fans, but not a single Ottawa jersey. Moving head office is an inspired idea.
Toronto is a very America-focused city, particularly in terms of sports culture. That, in turn, influences media and that distorts the national aesthetic. So, yes to the conclusion
Perhaps the teams should be moved entirely out of Montreal and Toronto if the fans won’t support them. I am sure there are smaller Canadian cities who would love to have a team.
Canadians are often criticized for a complacent acceptance of mediocrity vs. ambitious, risk-taking Americans. However, I think the CFL is a case where the league needs some acceptance of what it is vs. grander ambitions. Canada just doesn't have the market size needed to support American-style major sports league teams: we make it happen with hockey teams because it's our national sport, but really only Toronto is a big enough market to support other major league teams in baseball and basketball.
The beauty of the CFL has always been that it operates in smaller Canadian markets, and that it's been forced to stay a much smaller and community-based team than the big money, big business of the American major leagues. Recognizing that it's niche and staying within it creates a sustainable, enduring sports league in Canada.
I lived in Hamilton for some years, and even with the degradation of industry, Tiger Cats home games were always a huge deal in an otherwise increasingly depressed city.
It may be perverse to suggest an inverse proportion of CFL home city engagement with economic and industrial decadence, but I think it does hold water. Whether that will continue to be the case as the price of everything goes up (including tickets) except labour - and wouldn’t be surprised if that were the furtive pretext for these changes, frankly - remains to be seen.
The CFL brass is making a giant, short-sighted, unacceptable mistake, akin to expanding into Las Vegas and Shreveport. This has always been a Canadian game, not a NFL wannabe league, and fans know that (with the possible exception of TO). The Commissioner should resign now, the league offices moved to Winnipeg or Calgary, and we get somebody who wants to build something distinctly Canadian - not some bush league Americanized farm system.
Don't forget their other change next season: expanding the playoffs to eight teams, in a nine-team league.
The CFL does have some legitimate financial problems (and has had since the 1980s) and there aren’t any easy solutions. Growth is probably limited in Canada, and you have to wonder if the smaller field is the adjustment required to try another run at US expansion.
Of all the rule changes the most consequential is likely reducing the depth of the end zone (hands up, those of you of my vintage who recall when the end zones were 25 yards deep) which can obviously only REDUCE the number of TDs so yes, the purported reasoning here is total BS.
But a big yes to the main point of this piece which is that for economic (not just nationalistic) reasons you should want to keep the CFL as different from the NFL as reasonably possible - making the game look more similar to USA football will only highlight the inferior quality of CFL players versus NFL players. (To be clear, quality of players does not necessarily make a league more or less entertaining to watch - for me, NCAA football is VASTLY more interesting to watch than the NFL and the worst NFL team would destroy the best college team every time.) For example, wide fields and 2 downs create a need for a different style QB than the NFL making the CFL more attractive to smaller, faster QBs. This is less so than years ago due to changes in NFL philosophy (Warren Moon may not have had to come to the CFL if he were drafted today although Conredge Holloway probably still would) but it is still an issue. Different rules create a different (not necessarily inferior) product and also enables one to plausibly argue that the very best *of a certain type of player* can still be found in the CFL. In short, the fact Doug Flutie excelled in the CFL and not in the NFL should not be a stain on Flutie but rather a point in the CFL's favour. The CFL is better off with rules that make a team want a Flutie rather than the 100th best 6 foot 4 drop back QB on the continent.
Andrew, you're a little behind on one thing. "Engagement" means exactly one thing in modern sports - betting. The rules convergence with the NFL is to try to draw more companies into offering more and more granular betting on the CFL because their NFL tech and algorithms will be directly portable.
You're going to hate me for this, but the main reason I rarely watch CFL is because it is 3 down ball. If the league wants to make it more exciting ( in my opinion), make it 4 down. 2 and out doesn't give the fan time to get invested in the series and we're already looking at a punter. I honestly didn't even know the other issues mentioned were a thing.
Best Line story in months. Maybe you guys ought to change your "home" to sports. Sports Line works, might be taken, though I could see an immediate sponsor link-up potentially. And you are bang-on on all points Andrew. The 55 yard line is so uniquely Canadian that even the US folks comment on it, and how it supports the wider open nature of the game. Anyone that really loves gridiron football picks up why we score more points, despite having a down less, very quickly and field size including the deeper end zones is why. Of all the changes, the shortened end zones will result in LESS scoring and the same for the shifted goal posts. You will get longer field goal attempts (by definition 15 yards longer) so lower success and in the case that you "go for it" on 3rd down I would bet heavily that the 3rd down conversion rate (which doesn't guarantee any points) is significantly lower than the field goal success rate so more touchdowns? No guarantee by a Canadian mile. Congrats Stewie, you shot all of us fans in the foot. That makes you a Carney and just as traiterous.
Fully agree from Ottawa and Toronto. 26 year Argo season ticket holder until moving to Ottawa in the early 90’s. Repugnant ownership in Ottawa at that and the Rough Riders name change cooled my devotion to the CFL although I do attend the odd game and attended the Argo’s Grey Cup win in 2024. The rules and field dimensions make the game much more exciting and unpredictable as a result. This is all nonesense.
Just a thought, I appreciate them trying something, the CFL has such bad viewership and engagement...its honestly surprising it has survived, Im shocked it hasnt folded. Come on, a 9 team league where 6 make the playoffs?? In my personal circles sports viewership is huge, hockey, basketball, NFL, tennis, even baseball...nobody, and I mean nobody watches or cares about the CFL. Most dont even watch the grey cup game. Sure, thats one anecdote, but for a fairly typical guy in a typical neighborhood, with sports loving friends, thats not good. Harsh, but true. Good for them for making some changes if they think it will enhance viewership. .
I hate the change to the field. And I cannot imagine what was going on in the room when all 9 teams apparently agreed to these changes. Even worse, the Roughriders, Stampeders, Blue Bombers, and Alouettes share their stadiums with USport and occasionally High School teams making the field transitions absolutely stupid. But the fact in this story with which I agree wholeheartedly is that Toronto is not a "Canadian" city. It is global and American in orientation. We should not choose to make changes to our customs and traditions to accommodate Torontonians. Rather, we should expect Torontonians to choose to become Canadian.
I couldn’t agree more. Love the CFL’s incredible culture, on display at every Grey Cup. I did see Argo and Als fans, but not a single Ottawa jersey. Moving head office is an inspired idea.
Okay to be fair no one is going to admit to being an unironic Redblacks fan at this point.
I saw one with the ironic bag over her head for awhile.
Toronto is a very America-focused city, particularly in terms of sports culture. That, in turn, influences media and that distorts the national aesthetic. So, yes to the conclusion
Perhaps the teams should be moved entirely out of Montreal and Toronto if the fans won’t support them. I am sure there are smaller Canadian cities who would love to have a team.
Canadians are often criticized for a complacent acceptance of mediocrity vs. ambitious, risk-taking Americans. However, I think the CFL is a case where the league needs some acceptance of what it is vs. grander ambitions. Canada just doesn't have the market size needed to support American-style major sports league teams: we make it happen with hockey teams because it's our national sport, but really only Toronto is a big enough market to support other major league teams in baseball and basketball.
The beauty of the CFL has always been that it operates in smaller Canadian markets, and that it's been forced to stay a much smaller and community-based team than the big money, big business of the American major leagues. Recognizing that it's niche and staying within it creates a sustainable, enduring sports league in Canada.
Perfection. The CFL has pulled the "Leon McQuay" and fumbled on the one-yard line.
Losing the Snowbirds is a tragedy. But having them, Sarah McLachlan and Blue Rodeo at the opening is as Canadian as it gets.
I lived in Hamilton for some years, and even with the degradation of industry, Tiger Cats home games were always a huge deal in an otherwise increasingly depressed city.
It may be perverse to suggest an inverse proportion of CFL home city engagement with economic and industrial decadence, but I think it does hold water. Whether that will continue to be the case as the price of everything goes up (including tickets) except labour - and wouldn’t be surprised if that were the furtive pretext for these changes, frankly - remains to be seen.
The CFL brass is making a giant, short-sighted, unacceptable mistake, akin to expanding into Las Vegas and Shreveport. This has always been a Canadian game, not a NFL wannabe league, and fans know that (with the possible exception of TO). The Commissioner should resign now, the league offices moved to Winnipeg or Calgary, and we get somebody who wants to build something distinctly Canadian - not some bush league Americanized farm system.
Where’s the Elbows Up crowd when it comes to trashing the sovereignty of the CFL game in some misguided attempt to appeal to exactly who?
Don't forget their other change next season: expanding the playoffs to eight teams, in a nine-team league.
The CFL does have some legitimate financial problems (and has had since the 1980s) and there aren’t any easy solutions. Growth is probably limited in Canada, and you have to wonder if the smaller field is the adjustment required to try another run at US expansion.
Good piece.
Of all the rule changes the most consequential is likely reducing the depth of the end zone (hands up, those of you of my vintage who recall when the end zones were 25 yards deep) which can obviously only REDUCE the number of TDs so yes, the purported reasoning here is total BS.
But a big yes to the main point of this piece which is that for economic (not just nationalistic) reasons you should want to keep the CFL as different from the NFL as reasonably possible - making the game look more similar to USA football will only highlight the inferior quality of CFL players versus NFL players. (To be clear, quality of players does not necessarily make a league more or less entertaining to watch - for me, NCAA football is VASTLY more interesting to watch than the NFL and the worst NFL team would destroy the best college team every time.) For example, wide fields and 2 downs create a need for a different style QB than the NFL making the CFL more attractive to smaller, faster QBs. This is less so than years ago due to changes in NFL philosophy (Warren Moon may not have had to come to the CFL if he were drafted today although Conredge Holloway probably still would) but it is still an issue. Different rules create a different (not necessarily inferior) product and also enables one to plausibly argue that the very best *of a certain type of player* can still be found in the CFL. In short, the fact Doug Flutie excelled in the CFL and not in the NFL should not be a stain on Flutie but rather a point in the CFL's favour. The CFL is better off with rules that make a team want a Flutie rather than the 100th best 6 foot 4 drop back QB on the continent.
Andrew, you're a little behind on one thing. "Engagement" means exactly one thing in modern sports - betting. The rules convergence with the NFL is to try to draw more companies into offering more and more granular betting on the CFL because their NFL tech and algorithms will be directly portable.
You're going to hate me for this, but the main reason I rarely watch CFL is because it is 3 down ball. If the league wants to make it more exciting ( in my opinion), make it 4 down. 2 and out doesn't give the fan time to get invested in the series and we're already looking at a punter. I honestly didn't even know the other issues mentioned were a thing.
Go Chiefs, go Seahawks!!!
I agree the main difference is 3 vs 4 downs. The rest who can tell especially on TV.
Best Line story in months. Maybe you guys ought to change your "home" to sports. Sports Line works, might be taken, though I could see an immediate sponsor link-up potentially. And you are bang-on on all points Andrew. The 55 yard line is so uniquely Canadian that even the US folks comment on it, and how it supports the wider open nature of the game. Anyone that really loves gridiron football picks up why we score more points, despite having a down less, very quickly and field size including the deeper end zones is why. Of all the changes, the shortened end zones will result in LESS scoring and the same for the shifted goal posts. You will get longer field goal attempts (by definition 15 yards longer) so lower success and in the case that you "go for it" on 3rd down I would bet heavily that the 3rd down conversion rate (which doesn't guarantee any points) is significantly lower than the field goal success rate so more touchdowns? No guarantee by a Canadian mile. Congrats Stewie, you shot all of us fans in the foot. That makes you a Carney and just as traiterous.
Fully agree from Ottawa and Toronto. 26 year Argo season ticket holder until moving to Ottawa in the early 90’s. Repugnant ownership in Ottawa at that and the Rough Riders name change cooled my devotion to the CFL although I do attend the odd game and attended the Argo’s Grey Cup win in 2024. The rules and field dimensions make the game much more exciting and unpredictable as a result. This is all nonesense.
Just a thought, I appreciate them trying something, the CFL has such bad viewership and engagement...its honestly surprising it has survived, Im shocked it hasnt folded. Come on, a 9 team league where 6 make the playoffs?? In my personal circles sports viewership is huge, hockey, basketball, NFL, tennis, even baseball...nobody, and I mean nobody watches or cares about the CFL. Most dont even watch the grey cup game. Sure, thats one anecdote, but for a fairly typical guy in a typical neighborhood, with sports loving friends, thats not good. Harsh, but true. Good for them for making some changes if they think it will enhance viewership. .
I agree. Not every idea will work, but doing nothing isnt a strategy either.
I hate the change to the field. And I cannot imagine what was going on in the room when all 9 teams apparently agreed to these changes. Even worse, the Roughriders, Stampeders, Blue Bombers, and Alouettes share their stadiums with USport and occasionally High School teams making the field transitions absolutely stupid. But the fact in this story with which I agree wholeheartedly is that Toronto is not a "Canadian" city. It is global and American in orientation. We should not choose to make changes to our customs and traditions to accommodate Torontonians. Rather, we should expect Torontonians to choose to become Canadian.