87 Comments
User's avatar
Applied Epistemologist's avatar

We aren't talking about health care because the only ways to fix it are remigration, privatization, and rationing, and all of them will burst the boomer bubble of healthy affluence until death.

Our entire political structure rests on a stratum of boomers who believe that things can stay acceptable in Canada (for them) until they die. After which nothing matters.

When that changes, everyone in power now will be swept away.

IceSkater40's avatar

Boomers don’t compose the majority of the vote anymore. Not even close. I don’t think they influence politicians now as much as they’re given credit for. There are more millennials in Canada than boomers because of immigration. This may mean there aren’t as many voting millennials yet depending on where citizenship is sitting, but boomers have been dying for awhile now. They will continue to die. It’s about time everyone else stops blaming the boomers and is willing to step up and get involved at levels where policy decisions can be influenced. Blaming a generation for politician’s decisions seems like a lazy way out of engaging with a problem to me. You can’t indefinitely blame a disappearing generation with decreasing influence for things that need to be changed.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

Recent Abacus polling shows that 60+ are the only age group where support for the Liberals exceeds that for the Conservatives. Without the boomers, the Conservatives would have a substantial lead - and would have won last year's election.

John's avatar

I agree the boomers are keeping the liberals in power for now. The main reason IMO is that their house values are kept artificially high by a low Canadian interest rate policy. Since sovereign borrower rates are presently climbing substantially because of the huge deficits being run by both Canada and the US, low Canadian interest rates will cause the Canadian dollar to tank - not quite to Mexican peso rates IMO, but heading in that direction.

Letting the Canadian dollar drop offsets the impact of tariffs. Im pretty sure the 2 cent drop in the Canadian dollar more than offset the tariff related cost increase to US customers. Now in Canada you have a double whammy.

I expect the US to rely on more outright bans to protect their industries to avoid the exchange rate related dumping Canada is relying on.

Letting the medical services stagnate and tolerating huge delays also facilitates gaslighting of the sick elderly into using MAID which has the shortest wait time of any medical procedure. The problem for the liberals is that you may be killing off more Liberal than Conservative voters.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

Definitely. The boomers benefit from high asset values and low real incomes for workers, since they tend to consume services. While they also travel abroad, the ones who do that the most also have foreign assets - so they are protected against a declining CAD. Ruining Canada is in the boomers' selfish interest - if it doesn't happen too fast.

IceSkater40's avatar

Please look at population data for Canada. Also it’s about who shows up to vote. While I voted conservative in the last election, with how they’ve behaved since then I’m actually glad they didn’t win now. My generation will never determine an election. But boomers have lost the massive numbers as well.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

If 60+ is the only age group where Liberal support exceeds Conservative support, then that is necessarily the age cohort that Liberal rule depends on. (Barring absurdly improbable geographic distribution of support). Please review basic arithmetic.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Nice try.

If the Boomer cohort split evenly three ways- Conservative, Liberal, and NDP- Pierre Poilievre would be the Prime Minister of Canada.

The Boomer cohort- of which I am a reluctant member- has decided Canada will fix nothing, repair nothing, and improve nothing. Everything is just fine.

“Someday, all of this will be yours.”

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

A bit less "après moi le déluge" would be welcome.

Donald Ashman's avatar

You make some good points.

I would like to add two quick thoughts, if I may: my buddy’s son has just graduated from medical school. When he entered, approximately seven years ago, there were 187 students in his class. In the same program, for the 2026 school year, the new class is 189 students. That is, of course, in spite of the fact there are now 42 million of us to treat.

Secondly, the author makes a point of suggesting health care is the top priority for Canadians. A poll answers a question, but an election is how folks express how they actually feel. Reforming health care is not a priority for such an apathetic and unaccountable people.

Great post, friend.

KRM's avatar

Becoming a medical doctor should be similar difficulty to becoming a lawyer, not an astronaut.

Greg's avatar

this is correct. There is no cap on accountant admissions,

Set a bar and if met, you are in. As I said - it is moat building

Roki Vulović's avatar

If you read the history of the medical schools and associations in North America, they literally underwent a cutting of education and residency on purpose to "professionalize" medicine. To turn it into a guild to increase pay and job security.

When you have Oxbridge and Swiss educated doctors being told they aren't qualified enough to practice medicine in Canada within a month of moving to Canada, you know you have a racket.

Greg's avatar

You nailed it Donald. Less than 10 % acceptance for applicants. Compare that to the pop growth

It's called Moat building. Google it

U of CGY

• Recent Years (up to 2023): ~155 students annually

• 2024: 175 seats

• 2025–2026: Expanding up to 190 total seats across the main Calgary campus

Donald Ashman's avatar

Here are some more facts:

At University Hospital on Western’s campus, there are 200 people housed and cared for-taking a bed- that no longer require medical treatment.

One fellow has been there nine years.

Secondly, in the nursing home that cares for my brother-in-law, there are scores of folks who do not require long term care, but that can’t manage due to mental illness.

The indigent elderly can’t get care, so they stay in the hospital.

Our system is broken, and we vote in the same folks again, and again, and again.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Remember, that is just one hospital, and one long term care facility.

KRM's avatar

It's telling that this is rarely talked about in terms of the number of doctors we are producing per year, and even less so in comparative doctors per capita. It's always "there needs to be more funding", but more funding is never enough.

The fact that the medical community condones this deliberate depriving the population of medical care is fucking unconscionable.

Oh but if we make more doctors than the public system can support where do they work? Private clinics. That's the inevitable result if they create more doctors than the public system can sustain. The one result the gatekeepers can't tolerate.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Great facts.

My numbers are from Western.

Thank you for sharing.

Greg's avatar

Re - You mentioned UWO - from their website.

Western University’s Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry receives approximately 3,600 applications each year, interviews around 700 candidates, and enrolls an incoming class of roughly 190 students, yielding an overall acceptance rate of about 5.2%.

Greg's avatar

FYI - 15 % are foreign students ( they pay more ) like from Saudi Arabia who leave after grad. and 5 % don't graduate at all.

Plus these slightly larger cohorts are 8 yrs from being in the field. 2032 to 2034

Andrew Gorman's avatar

"Remigration" will not fix health care. Quite the opposite.

Assuming you mean immigrants leaving, that will do precisely the opposite because that would immediately make our population older... which means sicker.

You are (inadvertently, I assume) proposing making our demographic problem worse.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

You are assuming that recent temporary immigrants and PRs are a bigger share of health care workers than they are of older people. The average age of new immigrants is not all that much younger than the overall population and, being mostly from the third world and therefore likely less healthy than Canadians, likely to need more health care at any given age. And nothing prevents us remigrating selectively: keep the skilled health care workers while sending others home. That's still remigration.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

> You are assuming that recent temporary immigrants and PRs are a bigger share of health care workers than they are of older people.

Not at all. I'm assuming that immigrants are simply younger than the native born Canadian population... and they are. That's even more true of recent immigrants because they immigrated more recently.

And that means kicking them out makes our demographic problem of an aging society worse... and that makes the medical system less sustainable because old people have more health problems and more expensive health care.

Reality doesn't care about your feelings about immigrants or my feelings. You can't wish demographics away with handwaving "oh it isn't that much, I'm sure it doesn't matter".

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

This is completely absurd. If a population 10 old people and 10 young people have a certain need for health care, adding 10 more young people increases the need for health care. Sending them home reduces it. The fact that the percentage of olds in the population drops doesn't reduce demand.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Honest question, Andrew.

I am not trolling or baiting you.

When was the last time you were in a a Canadian Emergency Department waiting room in a major City?

(By major Canadian City, I would say London, or bigger-

500,000 or so)

Andrew Gorman's avatar

Without getting into my family's health, I'd say I have enough experience with the system to have a good idea of at least some of the problems. In my experience ERs are a place to avoid until you can't, although absurdly I've been directed to an ER for non-Emergency problems.

Why do you ask? (And is this about AE's counter-productive "remigration" silliness or did you mean to reply to my other comment?)

Donald Ashman's avatar

Okay; I accept your answer.

First of all, I don’t know what remigration means. If it means sending folks home who have overstayed their agreements, then I am for it. If it involves revoking the Citizenship of criminals, I am for it.

I am pro-immigration, using a points- based system that also excludes individuals from certain Countries. That system must be mutually beneficial for the Country, as well as the immigrant. I don’t believe in setting these folks up for failure.

Secondly, as you implied, we have some real problems in this Country, including our ER waiting rooms. Folks are showing up for the most ridiculous reasons, for symptoms we used to know how to manage and mitigate.

If the Government of Canada can lighten bail requirements and restrictions , it can exempt an ER doctor or nurse from prosecution of they send a patient home who doesn’t appear ill.

Our waiting rooms are full of folks who shouldn’t be there.

I am not trying to put words in your mouth, but do we agree?

KRM's avatar

Let's try it and find out.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

"Such a move would exacerbate a serious demographic problem and make our already precarious and increasingly unsustainable medical system worse. It is important to fix our medical system instead of breaking it with counter-productive plans you want to do for social reasons".

KRM: LEEERRRROOYYYYYYY JEEEEENKINS!!!!!!!!

But hey KRM... at least you have chicken.

KRM's avatar

Can't fault the WoW reference but check out what demographics dominate the long line in front of you in any GTA ER before being so certain that mass immigration isn't a net drain on the health system.

KRM's avatar

Liberals don't want to draw attention to the medical system because they would have to own the failure.

Conservatives don't want to talk about it because the only viable solution - the dreaded "two tier" health system used in every other country in the world and increasingly in Canada by stealth, is so politically toxic to Canada's helpless and easily manipulated population. It's a fantastic wedge issue against the Canadian right who are already suspected of being pro-American and therefore willing to bankrupt us all with "$500 Tylenols" in a system taken without modification from the US.

Australia has consistently better outcomes within a well regulated public/private system. We should start by looking at what they do right. But making any changes requires a level of maturity that Canadians are incapable of.

Donald Ashman's avatar

I have to give it to Mark Carney and the Liberals; they are expertly proficient at leveraging the ignorance of Canadians.

John Hilton's avatar

Australia has user fees for family MD appointments. In fact, half of the visit cost is paid by the patient.

Australia also has very struct immigration. There are no family reunification programs and immigrants with chronic health issues are denied admission. In addition, access to the public system depends on how many years you paid into it. Older immigrants have to pay a fee to make up for not paying in. In a friend’s case, each parent had to pay 100k each for admission.

Harsh but significant differences to what we do.

KRM's avatar

All quite sensible in my view. I'm sick of being the world's doormat while being hit over the head with "but Canadians are nice" when pointing out how we are being taken advantage of.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

> And that’s the last time we had any sort of national conversation about health care.

The end of the article has the answer... we are not going to have a "national" conversation about health care. We're having provincial ones. Quebec has a dual system and Alberta is rolling one out. Mr. Carney's contribution is to not strangle the baby of experimentation in the cradle.

The simple fact is that all successful countries have mixed public & private systems. Some are well implemented...some very much not. You're going to need some different approaches to find the ones that work best.

Bob Reynolds's avatar

Do you really think that support for the existing system is only coming from Boomers? Were that the case there would be a healthy debate and a push for reform. No, there is still majority support across all age groups for the inflexible and wasteful single payer system currently in place and this will only change with responsible leadership from our politicians, something so unlikely that change is just not in the cards any time soon.

Donald Ashman's avatar

I like the way you put that.

PETER AIELLO's avatar

While not denying that Trump is problematic we’ve fallen for a red herring approach where governments, political leaders and lesser lights use him as an excuse to mask and divert attention away from many real issues, such as healthcare, that need to and must be addressed constructively.

KRM's avatar

We're seeing the limits of how shamelessly and literally a politician can just answer "Trump" to any question and get away with it, in the BC election. It remains to be seen if this will be successful.

It's worked twice so far, in Ontario and Federally, in 2025, and gifted us the "most popular PM in Canadian history" despite few if any measurable accomplishments and a declining economy.

John Hilton's avatar

After 10 years of Trudeau, it’s going to take awhile.

Sean Cummings's avatar

Health care is unsolveable. Serious reform, I think, will create winners and losers. 'Universal' is a wonderful word but the reality is we have ten different health care systems, plus the territories. Each has its own service delivery model, funding and staffing models.

For me, faith in the public system has been shot for years. All the provinces are willing to discuss is Ottawa sending more money for health care and each province doesn't have a clue how to fix healthcare at home and across the country.

First step: Canadians need to stop losing their shit whenever there is any attempt to change the status quo

Fix Universal Healther Care= Kobayashi Maru.

Smoke 'em if you've got 'em. Public/Private health care is an inevitablity. As Palpatine would say: I have foreseen it.

Ian MacRae's avatar

There are 3 Canadian groups that have no-wait access to medical treatment: our MPs (through an unlimited health spending account, including foreign treatment), professional athletes (their teams pay immediately & directly for injured athletes) and doctors (they always know a colleague who will give them front-of-line access).

IceSkater40's avatar

I think there is general apathy around healthcare which is why people aren’t talking about it. Politicians lack the motivation because it’s not politically good to talk about it. We have a much less effective press overall so they’re not asking about it during election campaigns. And it’s harder than ever for people to reach politicians in a way that meaningfully influences them. So politicians get to talk about what they want to talk about which is the areas they feel like they can improve things or change things.

I think it’s misaligned incentives combined with a bureaucracy that isn’t willing or able to do anything to fix itself because there’s such a huge management class.

Not saying those are acceptable reasons - but maybe addressing the press or finding ways to actually force the topic into the public light is the first step.

Andrew Gorman's avatar

> I think there is general apathy around healthcare which is why people aren’t talking about it.

Not just apathy, but a (reasonable) concern about making things worse. As much as the current system is unsatisfactory, what if I told you that another option is to have substantially the very same coverage except now you can also pay a high deductible on all your visits.

Because that is a very real possible outcome for a lot of voters. Costs are rising, incomes aren't keeping up, the government is looking at heavy expenses in the future and the median voter isn't saying that's all going to be fine because their massive single-income family will be just fine.

We need a better system. But not every system is better and it's reasonable to be concerned that change means worse. I think that translates into avoiding the issue for many people.

Applied Epistemologist's avatar

Of course this is true. But why is it not politically good to talk about it?

IceSkater40's avatar

Because it’s not a quick fix. Because unions and lobby groups all want more money but aren’t willing to put in more work. There are systemic issues that require open discussion but they’re not things solved with adding $50 million to the budget. Complex problems that require time, planning, and action aren’t the forte of our politicians. Politicians want easy wins, short blurbs that can be produced as proof of their success, and want to claim the success for themselves. Something that may take a decade to lead to noticeable changes won’t ever benefit them.

Take doctors for instance - it’s not a funding problem, but a med school enrollment cap problem. Of all the people who want to be doctors, less than 10% get admitted into med school. Then there are limited residency spaces meaning that not everyone who finishes med school gets the experience they need to be fully licensed and practice independently. It’s not a willingness or money issue - the institutions and regulatory boards have created scarcity because it’s job security for doctors - they think they know how many doctors are needed and they’ve gotten that wrong.

We rely on recruiting from other provinces in AB to increase our supply of doctors - when we have 2 med schools that if they increased enrollment would lead to increased doctors within 7-8 years. But that’s not the problem politicians talk about. They throw money at healthcare as if that’s the only problem. And it’s not. You have to train more doctors to actually increase access to family doctors. The rest would follow with increased office spaces etc. and yes there’d probably need to be increased funding to pay the increased salaries. But first we need the doctors. The doctor shortage has been manufactured by limited admissions into med school and limited residency positions. Of course not every applicant is suitable to become a doctor. But more than 10% I’m sure are given what they’ve proven before applying for med school.

But this isn’t something that can get a sound bite in the evening news. And it makes a whole group of people worry that they’ll have less job security and lower income earning potential. So it’s not popular. But it’s the most meaningful long term thing that could be done across the country to increase doctors. It’s just not politically beneficial to tell voters you have a plan that will help them in 8-10 years.

Gerald Pelchat's avatar

And since both education and health care are Provincial responsibility, guess where we should be directing our attention.

Al's avatar

Think of the healthcare system as a ‘political tar baby’ - whoever touches it gets stuck in a mess.

It’s easier to squander tax money on bandaids than battling an entrenched bureaucracy.

dennis mcconaghy's avatar

What to talk about?

A system that is unsustainable by design.

Health care is not a right. It is a commodity.

Socialized healthcare may be a fundamentally better insurance model but not without the right of a Canadian to use their after tax dollars to acquire medical attention.

Dying on the cross of preventing “queue jumping” is wrong.

Fundamental freedom is compromised.

But even a socialized system cannot be sustainable at zero marginal cost for every citizen .

How dysfunctional does Canada choose to be?

KRM's avatar
Oct 1Edited

It's genuinely better for society if higher earning and wealthier people can pay to get faster and better medical care. The money they spend helps fund or at least take the burden off of the rest of the medical system, as many point out. But more fundamentally, these are the people you want to keep healthy so that they keep working and running their businesses to pay taxes to keep the rest of the system running.

A society with any sense would realize this.

dennis mcconaghy's avatar

Totally agree.

Ask the challenged Nenshi where is stands on this?

He will spew gibberish of leftist emphathy and dysfunction.

Clarke's avatar

Doesn't Gregory's experience in Quebec suggest the opposite is the case? Given a choice to bill privately or publicly, doctors will stampede to do the former and empty the public system of doctors.

KRM's avatar

We might want to look at how every other country on earth has handled that problem.

Perhaps we could phase it in by requiring that doctors only devote a certain percentage of their practice to private billed activities and the rest to the current system, while greatly ramping up the production of doctors.

What we have now clearly doesn't work no matter how much public funding is put in to it.

Mikey's avatar

Not talking about healthcare despite it being a huge concern is a widespread issue. I think the reason is that the solutions are complex and technical, so they don't lend themselves to political slogans. Most people know it's a problem, but they don't even really understand what the problem is or how to fix it. Just that it's not working. No shortage of people saying that the solution is the unrelated thing they wanted to do anyway of course. But that hobby-horse-riding naturally makes people suspicious that they're not trying to improve healthcare, so people don't like it.

The US experience over the past 15 years is instructive. Throughout that time, healthcare has been a major concern. The Affordable Care Act was a major reform that in a lot of technical terms really improved the system. For the better part of a decade it was a huge millstone around Democrats. Then when Republicans got into power, they tried to reform it and suddenly it was popular, or at least repealing it was unpopular. The real consensus was that there were big problems, but the voters were worried about changes.

You see this in Canada too, any reform is met with doom mongering "make it like American Healthcare". Then the usual rejoinder "It doesn't have to be American, it can be German or Swiss or whatever." Followed by the listener not knowing what that even means and tuning out.

Roki Vulović's avatar

You have quality, good access and cheap but you'll only ever have at most 2 out of 3. Canada chose quality and cheap. The US chose quality and good access.

As long as you don't have an immediate co-pay or cost to access medical care it will be rationed via access and/or quality instead. Rationing always occurs.

Many system around the world have built in co-pays and deductibles into their health insurance systems explicitly to deter wastage of care. These countries include Sweden, Switzerland, Singapore, Australia, etc.

Canadians are one of the few peoples in the world naive enough to think you can have a health care system without pricing to deter wastage.

Doug's avatar

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different results. Decades of increased funding, more staffing and better working conditions for front line staff have not delivered better outcomes.

Canadians need to wake up to the reality that as long as health care costs grow faster than GDP, they cannot be fully funded through taxes. Deductibles and co-payments are inevitable as even one time tax increases like a higher GST would not grow faster than GDP. Secondly, monopolies are terrible at innovation. Technology advances rapidly in healthcare. Government bureaucracies, union contracts and lack of competition impede innovation. Private delivery enables competition that forces innovation. Finally, healthcare is mostly a physically delivered local service that should be exclusive provincial jurisdiction. Federal involvement is both less efficient and blurs accountabiloty. The Canada Health Act needs to go and the Feds should exit tax room for the Provinces to collect more taxes to replace Federal transfers.

Healthcare is less of an election issue as few voters see much difference between various policy proposals that all focus on increased funding, more staffing and better working conditions for front line staff.

John Hilton's avatar

This is the smartest comment on this board. Health care growing faster than GDP leads to bankruptcy.

Marie Illerbrun's avatar

Love your post Mr Jack. We'll said and we'll written. Though I do believe our federal govt should be more involved with health care. Nationaly we are all suffering, its not a provincial issue anymore. I had to finally pull together a lot of money for arm surgery. I was getting no where with our free system, the were letting me look forward to the use of my hand because they couldn't act fast enough. My surgeon who I had to pay said it still might have been too late. The free system just wanted me to pop drugs every day to be able to stand the nerve pain till they might get around to surgery.

Lois's avatar

Please think this over. When national level changes are made, there is no easy evaluation of whether or not they are positive, and limited ability to fix things if the change is negative.

Case in point - wasn't it about the time of the Romanow Commission that the feds got cooperation from all provinces to reduce planned increases in physician education, in the mistaken belief that doctors were driving up health care costs to their own benefit and less doctors would result in expenditure control? If one province had tried it out first, the failure would not have spread to the whole country and would have been remediable.

But due to politics or poor research, or maybe ideologically pushed research, things went badly. We still do not have enough doctors and the factors that increase health care costs are still unknown and unaddressed. Meanwhile, Canadians wanting to be doctors aren't.

A more recent example is the Covid pandemic when the national system did not consult the federal and provincial emergency planning departments for planning the public had already paid for, nor ask what was needed. Instead the national government relied on UN bodies' expectations. Maybe the Liberals thought using the UN plan would enhance our international standing, but shouldn't the focus have been on people's health? We failed to contribute to the world's needs by contributing our expertise. There was limited buy in, impacts that should never have happened, and we dissed our own system.

There is no future in pushing a national system or letting the federal health department interfere with the provinces.

John Hilton's avatar

Romanow report had nothing to do with reduction medical training. The report was in 2001.

It was the NDP in British Columbia that started it in the early 90s. The other provinces have copied their path.

Donald Ashman's avatar

Your post does a good job addressing the supply side.

A very big problem is the demand side.

We have chosen reducing access as opposed to the price system rationing access.

Canadians have chosen an inferior system, and then expect it to operate like an efficient, productive and high outcome model.

It is like buying a 1986 Dodge Omni and expecting it to perform like a Mercedes AMG sports car.

Michele's avatar

Way way back in the 1980's a family member was part of a very high level committee, called the Ontario Council of Health, which was set up to advise the Minister and Cabinet on how to plan fiscally and demographically our system. One of their many conclusions was that the system which had originally been designed to provide public hospital only insurance was unsustainable.

In the following years hybrid models were recommended along the lines of the4 Swedish system where the public and private systems run parallel and those who can afford to pay do so. The biggest and stupidest aspect of this is the concept of free health care. It's not free and it's not competitive and so its damned expensive. It eats up at least a third of the Ontario budget. Yes the care is excellent when you're deathly ill or an accident victim but when a GP has a 1500 patient roster and you can't get a human on the phone the primary care system is in full on fail. Of course our health care system is not a value - only access to it regardless of ability to pay is the failed value. I'm happy to pay for my health care and joining Medcan is not a betrayal of our system. The system itself, crushed by its own weight, is betraying us.

A Canuck's avatar

QUOTE

The 2001 Romanow Commission reviewed the future of health care in Canada. Today, many of its recommendations remain largely unimplemented, and problems like national accountability, workforce planning and especially timely access remain effectively unchanged, if not worse. In 2002, Senator Michael Kirby released his report on the Health of Canadians — The Federal Role. Same problem: most of the benchmarks have not been achieved.

END QUOTE

Yes. And who is to blame? Provincial governments, led by premiers and parties that are too cowardly to level with their respective citizens about the costs of providing and fully funding public health care, and beating down protectionist professional lobbies, like the various provincial medical associations, that have instituted all sorts of unreasonable hurdles that are deliberate d-e-s-i-g-n-e-d to limit competition from foreign-educated doctors.

Provinces and the way the are run really are a curse on this country, in my view.

NB: I am not naïve about the federal bureaucracy, which is in a shambles due to the neglect and mismanagement of successive Conservative and Liberal governments in Ottawa. However, health care is clearly a provincial jurisdiction, so best to lay the blame firmly in the laps of the provinces.